Samuel Goldberg is the senior criminal defense attorney at the firm of Altman & Altman, LLP. A former prosecutor in New York, he has worked as a Boston defense attorney over 18 years. He has published various articles regarding the practice of criminal law and frequently provides legal analysis on radio and television, appearing on outlets such as the Fox News Channel, Court TV, MSNBC and The BBC Network.
To speak to Sam about a criminal matter call 617-492-3000.

June 25, 2009

A Boston Criminal Defense Lawyer Discusses Student Arrests And The Resulting Effects On A Student’s Future (Part Two)

As promised, our weekly "Attorney Sam's Take" discussion completes our examination of how involvement in the criminal justice system effects students.

We have discussed how, beyond the obvious, the arrest of a juvenile student in Massachusetts can seriously effect that student’s future plans. We have also mentioned how the earliest consultation with an experienced criminal defense attorney is vital in order to best attempt to prevent, or at least minimize, damage.

Of course, not all students are juveniles. Some are already adults. There are a few big differences. Remember how I wrote about the Juvenile System’s concerns being primarily rehabilitative? Well, such is not the case with adults. Further, while a juvenile’s prior record is often disregarded…no such luck for the adult.

The result of these differences?

Harsher realities.

Let’s take an example.

Last Thursday, 18-year-old Kyle R. (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) had a bit of trouble with the Taunton police. It seems he is being accused of driving drunk (aka OUI). Well, maybe a little more. He also faces charges of driving so as to endanger, carrying a dangerous weapon, (a spring-loaded folding knife) and violating the terms of a juvenile operator's driving license.

“What brought the lad to the attention of the law?”, you ask.

Well, the police say it was his driving his car into a speed limit sign and a fire hydrant just after 1:00 a.m.

Continue reading "A Boston Criminal Defense Lawyer Discusses Student Arrests And The Resulting Effects On A Student’s Future (Part Two)" »

May 20, 2009

What Should You Do If You Are Being Arrested In Boston? The Boston Criminal Lawyer Blog Answers The Questions Of What To Do Until You Contact Counsel

Once again, you are being arrested in Boston. Maybe you are out for a “night out on the town” and the town, and its inhabitants, has turned on you. Perhaps you are carrying something that has been branded as illegal…such as a gun or some drugs. Maybe there is a warrant out for your arrest and, for some reason, those police officers on the corner are looking at you kinda funny. Whatever the circumstances are, members of law enforcement are coming to approach you and they are not baring gifts…except for the Commonwealth’s Bracelets of Shame. Oh, how you wish you had your lawyer standing right beside you.

But you don’t.

You are on your own until you can get to the experienced criminal defense attorney whom you long ago learned from this daily blog you should consult.

What to do.

In today’s weekly Thursday Attorney Sam’s Take, we look at these crucial moments during which time you will decide how to respond to the approaching officers. If you are a regular reader to this blog, you probably know a lot of what I am about to tell you already. However, it is worth reviewing, since getting it wrong could cost you a lot of years.

Continue reading "What Should You Do If You Are Being Arrested In Boston? The Boston Criminal Lawyer Blog Answers The Questions Of What To Do Until You Contact Counsel" »

May 20, 2009

Massachusetts High School Senior Pleads Not Guilty to Saugus Pedestrian Accident that Killed a Senior Pedestrian and Seriously Injured Her Daughter

In Lynn District Court, teenager Jonathan Caruso attended his arraignment on Monday, pleading not guilty to charges of negligent vehicle homicide, being a minor transporting liquor, and operating under the influence of alcohol in the deadly pedestrian accident that killed a 67-year-old woman and seriously injured her daughter early Saturday morning. Caruso, 18, is a Saugus High School senior who had stayed out all night with friends after attending his prom the night before.

The deadly Massachusetts pedestrian accident occurred at Grove and Essex streets. A police report indicates that Caruso told them that he had been drinking and may have fallen asleep while driving. He says he regained consciousness after hitting a street sign. A friend who was in the car told him that he had struck two pedestrians. Caruso, who took a breath analysis test after the Saugus car accident, registered a .02% BAC. The legal limit for Massachusetts drivers under 21 is .02%.

Carol Marean died from her pedestrian injuries. Her 41-year-old daughter, Charlotte, sustained critical injuries. The two of them had gone out that morning to walk their dog.

The judge ordered the teenager held on $7,500 cash bail. Caruso will also have to abide by a 7pm to 7am curfew and go back to court in July for a pretrial hearing.

A Massachusetts OUI/DWI/DUI offense is a serious offense in the state—especially if someone was injured or killed as a result of the alleged drunk driving incident. An experienced Boston DUI lawyer can protect your rights and comb through all of the evidence to make sure that the best avenues of defense are available to you.

The more serious the criminal charges against you, the greater the penalties and the longer the sentencing periods that could await you. You need a good Massachusetts criminal defense law firm working for you.

Student arraigned in death of pedestrian, Boston.com, May 19, 2009

Friends: Teen Accused In Fatal DUI No, WCVB, May 18, 2009

Read the Police Accident Report, Boston.com (PDF)''

Related Web Resources:
Police arrest 34 people, many teens, in get tough move on public drunkenness at Comcast Center concert in Mansfield, Enterprise News, May 19, 2009

Continue reading "Massachusetts High School Senior Pleads Not Guilty to Saugus Pedestrian Accident that Killed a Senior Pedestrian and Seriously Injured Her Daughter " »

May 4, 2009

Limo driver arrested for driving drunk -was driving high school students at time of arrest- loss of license and maybe job to follow

‘Tis the season of high school proms. As a parent, I know the worry about what
"the kids" are doing out there. It did not occur to me that the adults in charge of the kids might need some worrying too. However, take Boston-area limosine driver, Brain H., 45 of Tewksbury, (hereinafter, the “Defendant”). Friday night, he was given the news that when this week began, he would be trading in his license for a new relationship…with a criminal defense attorney,

He was arrested in Lowell and charged with operating under the influence of alcohol…while transporting a group of high school students after the prom.

You see, a group of Lowell Catholic High School students hired the limosine from Lynette’s Limousine Service for the prom on Friday evening. However, during the outing, according to police, two of the girls noticed that the driver was driving erratically. One of them called a parent when the limo stopped at the Showcase Cinema at 32 Reiss Ave., police said.

Apparently, the students became suspicious that the Defendant ’s driving abilities had been hampered by drinking during the trip because he kept getting lost and repeatedly veered onto the rumble strips on the side of the road. According to the students, the situation got so bad that the students demanded that the Defendant pull over the limousine, which is why they stopped in the movie theater parking lot.

Officers said the parent who had been called immediately contacted Lowell police and the Defendant was arrested at the movie theater at 11:40 p.m.

According to police, the Defendant had initially left the area when the students refused to get back into the car, but returned shortly after, pleaded for the students to forgive him, and tried to convince them to get back into the limo. At one point he is said to have “…actually put his hands in the praying position and said ‘Please, I’m sorry, I made a mistake,” according to the students.

The students did not go for it and the parents are likewise not in a forgiving mood.

Continue reading "Limo driver arrested for driving drunk -was driving high school students at time of arrest- loss of license and maybe job to follow" »

April 30, 2009

Massachusetts Man Charged with DWI Accident Wants Victims’ Credibility Questioned

In Massachusetts, a former Massachusetts National Guard sergeant is combating DWI charges involving a Concord bicycle accident that injured two cyclists. Adam Lamothe, 26, was going to plead guilty to the criminal charges of two counts of conduct after an accident and aggravated driving while intoxicated, but now he’s retained a new Massachusetts criminal defense law firm and he wants to question the victims’ credibility.

The deadly Concord DWI accident occurred in August 17, 2007 when they were struck by Lamothe's motor vehicle on South Main Street early in the morning. The two bicyclists, Daniel Gallant and Adam Boyer, got hurt. Boyer, who sustained a traumatic brain injury and a fractured skull, almost died. Meantime, Lamothe didn’t stop the car after striking the two men. When police apprehended him, he had a .17% blood alcohol level.

It turns out, however, that both men have criminal records. Now, Lamothe’s attorney wants to use these past convictions, which are admissible at trial, to help jurors determine whether the victims can be trusted to tell the truth. Gallant, who was convicted of child sexual assault, served 10 years in prison. Lamothe’s defense team believes this is important, because Gallant tried to conceal some of this history during a pretrial deposition. Boyer, was convicted in 1998 of physical assault.

It will be up to a judge to determine whether revealing the details of the men’s criminal records will outweigh any unfair prejudice or mislead a jury. Merimack County prosecutor Wayne Coull wants to keep the two men’s criminal histories out of court. He doesn’t believe their credibility should be an issue for this case because the two men weren’t even aware that they’d been hit by a motor vehicle until they recovered from their injuries.

Combating Criminal Charges
If you have been charged with a Massachusetts crime, you are entitled to representation by a Boston criminal defense law firm that will exhaust every avenue of defense on your behalf. Situations and circumstances are not alway what they seem and having an experienced criminal defense lawyer by your side is the best way to make sure that you don't get lost in the legal system and that there is someone fighting for you to ensure the best outcome possible for your case.

Cyclists' past crimes may enter DWI trial, Concord Monitor, April 29, 2009

Driver Charged With DWI After Bicyclists Hit, WCVB, August 17, 2009


Related Web Resources:
Drunk Driving, Justia

Criminal Defense Lawyer, FAQ

Continue reading "Massachusetts Man Charged with DWI Accident Wants Victims’ Credibility Questioned" »

April 28, 2009

Lawyer remains jailed; charged with OUI, driving with suspended license and giving false name

A north of Boston attorney has found herself on the chair most often occupied by her clients. At least, that is, in court. Otherwise, she is in custody, held without bail, for driving offenses.

Tracy T., 32, of Revere (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) is being held without bail on what the Commonwealth alleges to be her third drunk driving charge. Well, that was one reason.

The other reason, according to prosecutors, is that she gave false information to the patrolman who stopped her.

The alleged event took place in Marblehead last Thursday morning. The Defendant was pulled over by police. Upon questioning, she is said to have given the police a phony name, date of birth and a Social Security number that turned out to be that of an elderly man. She said she didn't have her license on her, then told the officer that it was expired.

When police determined who she was, The Defendant became apologetic and then allegedly gave the kicker line, "You aren't going to arrest me, are you? I can't get arrested. I am an attorney," according to police.

Given that her line of argument was not persuasive under the circumstances (which allegedly include her failing two of three field sobriety tests and then registering a .22, more than three times the legal limit, on a portable Breathalyzer, the answer was in the affirmative.

Continue reading "Lawyer remains jailed; charged with OUI, driving with suspended license and giving false name" »

March 31, 2009

Boston Road Drunk Driver Asked, “Do You Want A Lawyer With That Burger?”

Raymond A., 51, of Hampden, (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) was hungry. He just wanted a burger. But he was watched by an ambulance driver. Now, he needs an attorney.

Springfield District Court was the venue for the Defendant’s little adventure to end. According to law enforcement, he had been driving under the influence of alcohol.

The adventure began at approximately 2:00 a.m. as an AMR ambulance driver observed the Defendant’s pickup truck driving erratically in AMR’s parking lot, according to Sgt. John M. Delaney, executive aide to Police Commissioner William J. Fitchet.

Perhaps thinking that his services might be needed at any moment, the ambulance driver followed the truck.

She did this while keeping the police informed of the truck’s route of travel while keeping it in sight.

Finally, she followed the truck into a McDonalds on Boston Road, where the Defendant, the driver of the truck, attempted to order food from a drive-up window.

There was a problem with the service…there wasn't any. The place was closed.

Continue reading "Boston Road Drunk Driver Asked, “Do You Want A Lawyer With That Burger?”" »

March 11, 2009

Former Boston Hit And Run Driver Must Have Golden-Tongued Attorney After Driving Drunk

It is time for the “Hey, I’ll Bet I Can Make This Situation Worse” Club to announce its new spin-off organization, “Bet They Nail Me This Time!” I would like to nominate for the BTNMTT initial poster child a certain 19 year old woman, Elizabeth F. (hereinafter, the “Defendant”). Lately, she hails from Norfolk. However, back in 2006, she and her lawyer were trying to keep her free after she was involved in a Boston fatal hit-and-run case.

On Sunday, the Defendant, still on probation for the earlier case, was arrested in Ashland on drunk driving charges after she was found passed out behind the wheel of her car that had gone off the road, police said.

She was not alone this time. She was with elder 20 year old Carrie O. (hereinafter, the “Co-defendant”)… who was also passed out in the car.

As a result of their investigation, police say that the women appeared to be passed out from alcohol, not from any injury they received when the car crashed into a snow bank.

Fortunately, nobody was on the receiving end of the vehicle this time.

Continue reading "Former Boston Hit And Run Driver Must Have Golden-Tongued Attorney After Driving Drunk" »

March 11, 2009

Massachusetts Police Say Economic Woes Have Led to More Break-Ins, Larceny, Domestic Violence, and Other Crimes

Police in Massachusetts say they believe that the increase in car break-ins, burglaries, scams, larcenies, and domestic violence crimes throughout the state can be attributed to the recent economic crisis. For example, the Boston Globe is reporting that in:

• Lawrence, Massachusetts: Burglaries have already increased by 52% compared to last year.
• Lowell, Massachusetts: There has been a 21% increase in thefts and larcenies, as well as an increase in fraud cases.
• Hingham, Massachusetts: Between October 2008 through February 2009, there were 57 reports of domestic violence-related crimes (up from 35 domestic violence incidents the year prior).
• Boston, Massachusetts: While large crimes are down throughout the city, certain areas have seen an increase in robberies, thefts, and burglaries.
• Between January 1 through March 1, 2009, the Suffolk district attorney’s office assessed 256 child abuse cases, which is almost twice the number of cases reported for the same period in 2008.

According to police, loss of work, loss of income, foreclosures, and loss of quality of life may be leading to desperation, frustration, anger, stress, arguments and fights between couples and business partners, drinking, and drugs.

Police departments throughout Massachusetts are also reporting some unusual crimes that could be a further reflection of the tough times that people are facing:

• A Ludlow bank was robbed two times in a little over a year in a town that hadn’t experienced a bank robbery in 20 years.
• In Hingham, one man was accused of assaulting his spouse after he was laid off from work.
• One Quincy theft crime that occurred last December involved robbers taking three snowplow blades.
Domestic violence programs throughout Massachusetts are reporting an increase in the number of battered women asking for help.

It doesn’t help that the economic crisis is forcing police departments to cut back on budgets, which means there are less resources and staff to deal with the increase in Massachusetts crimes.

Economy fuels rise in crime, police say, Boston.com, March 10, 2009

Massachusetts Crime Rates 1960 - 2007, Disaster Center

Related Web Resources:
Massachusetts State Police

Continue reading "Massachusetts Police Say Economic Woes Have Led to More Break-Ins, Larceny, Domestic Violence, and Other Crimes" »

March 5, 2009

North Of Boston Driver Finds That The Alcohol – Cocaine-Driving Combination Makes Prosecuting Attorneys Unhappy

How did you spend your Saturday night last weekend? Well, you can tell me about it (if you really want to call me about that), but a certain gentleman from Boston’s Northern Neighbor, Salem has only his own attorney to tell about it. And, if he wants to get out of jail anytime soon, he had better hope that the lawyer is gifted in spinning that story.

Ronald M. 46, (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) was arraigned this week on a series of charges stemming from the 12:50 a.m. crash at the intersection of Bridge and Webb streets, including second-offense drunk driving and a third offense of driving while under the influence of drugs, driving while his license was under suspension for a prior drunk-driving conviction, leaving the scene of a personal injury and property damage accident, driving to endanger, two counts of resisting arrest, and failing to stop for police.

Not only this…but he did it in a borrowed vehicle!

Prosecutors in Salem District Court promptly filed a motion requesting that he be held without bail. Judge Robert Cornetta scheduled a hearing on that request for Friday. In the meantime, the Defendant will remain in custody at Middleton Jail.

Police say the Defendant, driving a borrowed pickup truck, ran a red light and "T-boned" an SUV, sending it into a utility pole. The impact sheared the pole and crushed the SUV, trapping the driver. The driver had to be extricated from the wreckage but declined medical attention.

As police converged on the scene, the Defendant, apparently a member of the famed “Hey, I’ll Bet I Can Make This Situation Worse” club tried to flee, police said in a report.

Continue reading "North Of Boston Driver Finds That The Alcohol – Cocaine-Driving Combination Makes Prosecuting Attorneys Unhappy" »

February 24, 2009

Boston Celebrity And Her Lawyer At The Bar In Drunk Driving Case

You know, sometimes the weather gets to everyone. The cold Northeast winters…except for those midwinter days when we get 70 degree weather and then a blizzard the next day. It’s confusing and it could lead a person to drink. And that is basically what happened to Boston’s free-lance meteorologist Melissa B. (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) last Friday. Now, the 39-year-old celebrity needs a defense attorney to ensure that she is able to remain free to even see the weather.

It happened last Friday morning. A professional, she was back on the air that night.

The Defendant was driving the 2004 Cadillac Escalade at approximately 1:35 a.m. when she passed a state police trooper in the left lane of Soldiers Field Road “going well over” the posted speed limit according to state police spokesman Dave Procopio.

The Defendant’s vehicle “nearly struck the front of his cruiser as it cut in front of him,” said Procopio, quoting from the police report. The trooper reported the Defendant was driving between 50 to 55 mph (the posted speed limit was 40) and was “weaving between” the travel lanes. The road conditions were poor, the trooper stated, and Soldiers Field Road was covered in sleet and snow.

Procopio said the trooper pulled the Defendant over and he “observed a smell of alcohol” when he approached the driver’s side. The trooper reported that the former WBZ-TV meteorologist asked him a question that was “incoherent.”

Continue reading "Boston Celebrity And Her Lawyer At The Bar In Drunk Driving Case" »

February 2, 2009

Boston-area Law Enforcement Endangered By Drivers Needing Defense Lawyers

It has been a difficult and dangerous time for Boston-area police officers. While perhaps not intentional, recent tragedies and near-tragedies remind us that some of those we represent as defense attorneys often endanger not only themselves, but everyone around them when driving dangerously.

Including police officers. Let's look at two recent examples.

You have probably already heard about State Police Captain Richard J. Cashin, 52, father of four, who died last Wednesday when his cruiser crashed into a utility pole. It has now been determined that he was likely enroute to help Saugus police pull over a car that was reportedly driving erratically.

About a mile and a half from the crash site, Saugus police had pulled over the driver who, police later found out, was texting while driving, said Saugus Lt. Michael Annese. He believes it’s likely that is where Cashin was headed.

State Police spokesman Dave Procopio said “Based on the proximity of the time and location and the type of police officer Capt. Cashin was - always looking to assist other officers - you could draw a reasonable inference that he had begun traveling up Route 1 to look for an erratic driver, who posed a threat to the public, at the time he lost his life,” Procopio said.

Witnesses told police the car’s lights and sirens were not on prior to the crash, Procopio said.

Continue reading "Boston-area Law Enforcement Endangered By Drivers Needing Defense Lawyers" »

January 27, 2009

Framingham Judge Wants DA’s Office to Retry 2006 Drunk Driving Case Because of Possible Judicial Misconduct

Framingham Judge Robert Greco wants the district attorney’s office to retry a 2006 Massachusetts drunk driving case because he says there is evidence that judicial misconduct took place. Earlier this month, Greco denied the DA’s motion to reconsider this order.

On January 14, Grego ruled that that there was evidence showing that the judge in the trial, Nantucket first justice Joseph I. Macy, had gone into the jury room while deliberations were taking place and did not give jury members sufficient instructions about how to decide the case.

Last November, however, Macy gave testimony that he did not enter the deliberation room while jurors were deciding on defendant John Bresnahan's verdict. He also says that he has never entered a jury room during deliberations throughout his entire judicial career. He did, however, admit to speaking with jurors after they issued a guilty verdict against Bresnahan. Macy says that going into the room to thank jurors and answer any questions is standard practice once a trial is over.

A number of court officers also testified that Macy did not enter the room while the jury was deliberating. However, three of the four jurors who gave testimony during a post-verdict juror inquiry claim that Macy entered the room during deliberations to answer a question.

Now, Grego wants the guilty verdict vacated and the case retried. The 2006 verdict was Bresnahan’s fourth DUI conviction. Assistant District Attorney Tom Shack, however, says he will appeal Greco’s decision. He says the DA's office believes that Greco is in error.

Judicial Misconduct
Judicial misconduct can occur when the Code of Judicial Conduct has been violated. Some examples of judicial misconduct:

• Conflict of interest
• Impropriety
• Misconduct during an election campaign
• Ex parte communication

Evidence of Misconduct Found in '06 Drunk Driving Trial, The Inquirer and Mirror, January 26, 2009

Massachusetts Commission on Judicial Conduct


Related Web Resources:
Massachusetts Law About Drunk Driving

Continue reading "Framingham Judge Wants DA’s Office to Retry 2006 Drunk Driving Case Because of Possible Judicial Misconduct" »

January 13, 2009

Boston Area Police Officers Approve Of Defense Attorneys When Facing Charges Of White Collar Crimes And Drunk Driving

So far, 2009 has been an active year for certain Boston-area law enforcement officials in terms of legal problems. Take for example Stoughton’s police chief, Manuel, C., 57 (hereinafter, “Defendant 1”), this week appearing beside his defense attorney, standing trial on white collar charges that he tried to use his authority to threaten a former Stoughton businessman in April 2002 to drop a complaint of misconduct against a former police sergeant.

He’s also accused of trying to cover up the sergeant’s attempt to coerce a settlement of a civil claim against the businessman.

Defendant 1 has been on paid leave since he was indicted nearly four years ago. He began trial in Dedham Superior Court yesterday.

Then there is the tale of Brockton Police Officer Daniel M., 31, (hereinafter, “Defendant 2”) who has finally returned to work for the first time since his May 2005 arrest on a rape charge. He is now undergoing retraining before hitting the streets again, Police Chief William Conlon said.

Superior Court Judge Paul Troy is said to have dismissed the rape charge last week after a series of legal proceedings and after the woman making the allegations failed to appear in court at any time. Because the charge was dropped, Defendant 2 will receive back pay from the city. Conlon said the city is now calculating that amount.

Defendant 2 had already served a five-day suspension given by then Police Chief Paul Studenski in connection with the case, Conlon said.

Continue reading "Boston Area Police Officers Approve Of Defense Attorneys When Facing Charges Of White Collar Crimes And Drunk Driving " »

January 9, 2009

Recent Celebrity DUI Arrests Include Charles Barkley and Sam Shepherd

The year 2009 has just began, and already, there are already a couple of celebrity DUI arrests in the police record books. On New Year’s Eve, television commentator and former basketball star Charles Barkley was arrested in Arizona on suspicion of drunk driving after he ran a stop sign. He underwent field sobriety tests at the scene, but refused to take a breath test. Barkley was given a blood test at the police station and was cited for driving while being impaired.

On Saturday, Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright and movie star Sam Shephard was arrested for allegedly drunk driving and speeding in Illinois after leaving a bar. His blood-alcohol level was reportedly two times the legal limit. Shephard was released Sunday after posting bond.

Last Friday, television star Heather Locklear’s DUI case was dismissed after she entered a no-contest plea to a reckless driving misdemeanor charge. Locklear had been arrested and charged last September with misdemeanor driving under the influence of prescription drugs. Now, she must undergo probation for 3 years, take part in a 12-hour drug education program, and pay a $700 fine.

Celebrities are not the only ones at risk of drunk driving, especially during the holiday season. Over New Year’s Eve, the Massachusetts State Police Department increased its patrol efforts to keep drunk drivers off the streets. An additional 410 patrols were on duty.

State police say that as of December 30, they had made 5,004 OUI arrests for operating under the influence in 2008—a 7% increase from 2007, while Massachusetts OUI crashes were down by 6% at 584 accidents.

With additional police vigilance comes more arrests. However, just because a person has been arrested for a Massachusetts OUI does not mean that they are guilty of the charges or will be convicted.

Barkley 'disappointed' after DUI arrest, The Boston Channel, January 5, 2009

Sam Shephard Arrested for DUI, Boston Herald, January 5, 2009

Locklear DUI case dismissed after plea deal, MSNBC, January 2, 2009

Police Crack Down On Drunken Drivers, WCVB, December 30, 2008

Continue reading "Recent Celebrity DUI Arrests Include Charles Barkley and Sam Shepherd" »

January 2, 2009

Samuel’s Take: A Boston Drunk Driving Verdict From An Experienced Defense Lawyer’s Files

Happy new year to you all.

In each daily installment of the Boston Criminal Lawyer Blog, I tell you that, should you have reason to believe that someone is mentally measuring you for a pair of the Commonwealth’s bracelets of shame and a warm cell, you should engage an experienced criminal defense attorney.

The reasons may be obvious to some. There may be some among you, however, who think, “Aw, that’s just Goldberg tooting his own horn again. My case is so simple, a trained chimpanzee with a law degree could handle it. Besides, experienced lawyers are more expensive than those without experience.

Well, no and yes. I have not yet met any monkeys who have made it all the way through law school (although I have had my suspicions in some cases), and, yes, experienced attorneys usually cost a little bit more.

Every case is different and some cases seem more straight- forward than others. However, any case can have its little surprises. Further, even the simplest of cases can be lost.

The fact is, there are certain things that one can only pick up through experience. As in most professions, one can develop a “sense” about things.

This is especially true at trial.

Speaking of trials, I have also told you that, at times, police officers (like any witnesses) may not find it necessary to limit themselves to the truth.

How dare I?

Continue reading "Samuel’s Take: A Boston Drunk Driving Verdict From An Experienced Defense Lawyer’s Files" »

December 23, 2008

North Of Boston, A Convicted Drunk Driver Believes She Has Gotten A Gift…But Turns Out To Need A Defense Attorney To Go Along With It

North of Boston, Evelyn C., 74, (hereinafter the “Defendant”) thought she had reason to celebrate. Instead, she found that the gift she thought received from the Registry of Motor Vehicles (RMV) necessitated a little something extra…namely, a criminal defense lawyer

You see, like many of us, she was driving around the morning of December 17th. Unlike many of us, however, she was not supposed to be behind the wheel at all until 2015.

That's what a Salem District Court judge had told her last August when he sentenced her after her third operating under the influence conviction.

She knew it and the court knew it…but, the RMV…not so much.

Just last month, in fact, they issued a brand new shiny driver’s license for the Defendant.

An isolated occurrence?

Again, not so much.

You see, her case is one of what the state auditor last summer estimated as thousands of drivers whose licenses were never yanked by the RMV despite court orders following drunken driving and other motor vehicle convictions.

Continue reading "North Of Boston, A Convicted Drunk Driver Believes She Has Gotten A Gift…But Turns Out To Need A Defense Attorney To Go Along With It " »

December 22, 2008

North Of Boston Gentleman Possesses Weapons That Any Defense Attorney Could Have Told Him He Was Not Allowed To Posess After A History Beating People With Them

How did you begin your weekend? I began mine by driving to court in Boston, doing other lawyer-like things at the office and then running home to “hunker down”, as the radio told me to do, because of the impending snow. I also dug out my car a couple dozen times.

I felt alittle put-upon by all that nasty snow.

In retrospect, though, I feel luckier. After all, 31-year-old Jason R. of Pelham, Massachusetts (hereinafter, the “Defendant”)did not have to shovel any snow on Friday, or Saturday or even Sunday. That was done for him.

In federal custody.

You see, he was arrested on Friday on federal warrants in Framingham stemming from a Pelham police investigation concerning illegal firearms possession.

Well, it was not just the fact that he was in possession of the guns…it was that he was a felon in possession of the guns.

The Defendant and law enforcement have had a bit of a stormy relationship over the past years.

Continue reading "North Of Boston Gentleman Possesses Weapons That Any Defense Attorney Could Have Told Him He Was Not Allowed To Posess After A History Beating People With Them" »

December 12, 2008

North Of Boston Does Its Best To Catch Up To Boston Proper’s Busy Drug Trade

Taghi T., 28, of Boston, (hereinafter, “Defendant 1”) was awaiting his mail on Wednesday. He did not realize that a criminal defense attorney would need to be involved.

Apparently, he should have.

Law Enforcement had intercepted the parcel and when Defendant 1 went to UPS in downtown Boston to claim it, he received the Commonwealth Bracelets of Shame instead. You see, the postal workers were really police officers. The package had a bit of marihuana in it…a “bit” being defined here as 10 pounds worth. And you know how the police are…always suspicious. For some reason they suspected there might be more goodies to be found, so they decided to search his Boston home.

They turned out to be right. They found a large amount of materials typically found in any healthy drug operation, according to Suffolk County prosecutors. Well, that is, if you consider 800 grams of cocaine, another 15 pounds of marijuana, more than 200 prescription pills, $25,235 in cash and various drug paraphernalia such as scales, cutting agents, and bags a “large amount”.

The Commonwealth does, incidently.

And so it was that Defendant 1 found himself before a Boston court facing various drug charges such as cocaine trafficking and drug possession.

But, hey, that’s the “big city”, right? If you are talking about Massachusetts, Beantown is the “big leagues”! The urban Mecca! What do you expect?

Continue reading "North Of Boston Does Its Best To Catch Up To Boston Proper’s Busy Drug Trade" »

December 11, 2008

Massachusetts State Trooper And Proclaimed Scourge Of Drunk Drivers Accused Of Brutality And Perjury

The Boston Herald reports about what are generally considered a couple of those “dirty little secrets” about the Justice System. They involve rather inconvenient truths that are particularly disconcerting, and so tend to be ignored, in the criminal justice arena.

And by the way....they are probably truths you have even suspected at times.

The first one is that, sometimes, police officers overdo it when it comes to force.

The other one is a bit more complicated, but I have faith in you that you can follow it.

Ready?

Step 1- Sometimes, people lie while under oath.

Step 2-Police officers are people

Step 3- Sometimes police officers lie while under oath.


No, this does not mean all police officers and it does not mean this happens in every case. I can tell you from experience, however, that I have experienced cases wherein police officers did not feel overly burdened by the boundaries of the truth.

Usually, these instances go without any penalty to the officer, although it is the crime of perjury just as when one of us “regular people” do it.

Not this time, though.

Continue reading "Massachusetts State Trooper And Proclaimed Scourge Of Drunk Drivers Accused Of Brutality And Perjury" »

December 8, 2008

Massachusetts Bank Robbery Suspects Continue To Engage Police In High Speed Chases And Win… Larger Criminal Sentences

Happy Monday. How did you start your weekend? I hear a lot of people went shopping. At Altman & Altman, LLP., we moved our offices next door.

In Fitchburg, Massachusetts, a gentleman had a high speed chase with an officer.

As usual, he did not win. He did, however, manage to injure a police officer, which successfully gained him membership into the infamous “Hey, I’ll Bet I Can Make This Worse” Club.

Of course, according to authorities, James T., 36 of Templeton (hereinafter, “Defendant 1”) had not exactly been the pillar of good judgment before the chase. There had already been a little matter of that warrant out for his arrest in connection with the robbery of the Fitchburg Savings Bank in Parkhill Plaza in April 2007.

Last Friday, police say that Detective Perry Pappas saw Defendant1 come out of a Marshall Street house around 1 p.m. and get into a black Saturn driven by a woman. The Detective followed the Saturn in an unmarked cruiser through city streets, and called for marked cruisers to help him with the arrest.

So far, so good.


Marked cruisers arrived around the intersection of Blossom and Crescent Streets. They signaled for the driver of the Saturn to stop.

That did not go over so well.

The Saturn did not stop. Instead, it drove along several more streets in the Fitchburg State College area and then hit another car at Pearl Street and Myrtle Avenue; that car, in turn, struck the cruiser driven by Police Officer Michael Rochette, police said.

The female driver of the Saturn was arrested at the scene and was taken to Leominster Hospital. Officer Rochette and three people in the car his cruiser collided with were taken to Leominster Hospital with what police said are non-life-threatening injuries.

Defendant 1, however, was not done yet.

Continue reading "Massachusetts Bank Robbery Suspects Continue To Engage Police In High Speed Chases And Win… Larger Criminal Sentences" »

December 2, 2008

Massachusetts Drunk Driver Assaults Police And Faces Charges Of Attempted Murder

Sometimes it’s the opposite of a chase…!

Yesterday’s daily blog focused on police chases and attempts by defendants to get away from the scene of the alleged crime.

But in Weston, on Route 117 early Saturday morning, Joaovitor R, 18, of Watertown (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) is said to have driven right into two police officers.

Literally.

Yesterday, the Defendant appeared before the court to answer various charges related to the event. Although pleading not guilty, he is being held pending a dangerousness hearing at Waltham District Court.

The event took place as Sgt. Keith Kasprzak and Officers Steve McShane and David Zampell were investigating an unrelated accident involving a pickup truck that hit a utility pole in the Conant Road area of Route 117 at 2:30 a.m. on Saturday.

As Officer Zampell was directing westbound traffic, a car approached him. It was allegedly the Defendant.

The car stopped within inches of the officer.

And then the driver hit the gas.

Continue reading "Massachusetts Drunk Driver Assaults Police And Faces Charges Of Attempted Murder" »

December 1, 2008

Massachusetts Alleged Drunk Drivers And Robbers - Escape Statistics Are In: You Are Losing

North Attleboro, Massachusetts, had more than its fair share of attempted escapes from law enforcement last week. Two such cases graced the hallowed halls of Attleboro District Court last Friday.

One case involved some teenagers who led the police on a high-speed chase into the welcoming arms of Rhode Island. The teens, a 15-year-old girl and three lads of 17, all of Providence, (hereinafter, “Defendants 1”) ,allegedly broke into vehicles at an Attleboro movie theatre and then took off in a stolen car.

Defendants 1 then led the police on a chase on Interstate 295 at speeds up to 100 miles per hour. Once they reached Rhode Island, the North Attleboro police broke off the chase.

Home free?

Afraid not.

Three of them were returned to Massachusetts (one is trying to fight extradition) to answer charges of breaking and entering, vandalism charges and possession of a stolen motor vehicle. The driver also faces traffic offenses.


You see, the North Attleboro police are not alone in the world. They have friends. Take Rhode Island law enforcement, for example. Rhode Island authorities picked up the chase, which ended on Route 7 in Smithfield, R.I., when the vehicle crashed into a brushy area off the highway.

So, other than the Massachusetts charges, they all now all face related charges in Rhode Island.

While two of the above-mentioned boys were arraigned in North Attleboro District Court last Friday, they had plenty of people to talk to. For example, there was Dennis W., 23, of North Attleboro (Hereinafter, “Defendant 2”). The police say that Defendant 2, an alleged drunk driver, struck a utility pole and drove off before calling a friend to drive his car.

Continue reading "Massachusetts Alleged Drunk Drivers And Robbers - Escape Statistics Are In: You Are Losing" »

November 26, 2008

North And South Of Boston, Sex Trade Stings Are In Full Swing

As we near Thanksgiving, we look around for reasons to be thankful. True, economic times are tough and getting tougher. However, it would appear that all the violent crimes and drug dealing in Lynn, Massachusetts, has been stopped. No more guns rape, robbery or murder. It would appear that even the drunk driving problem is under control.

Now, the police have the time and resources to concentrate on other vicious crimes plaguing our society.

Prostitution, for example.

This past Saturday, a well timed police prostitution sting was said to be different than others done in the recent past. According to the Lynn Item, it was conducted in “broad daylight”.

No pun intended, I’m sure.

“For the city of Lynn, unfortunately, it’s a 24/7 problem,” said Sgt. Rick Carrow of the world’s oldest profession. He is the head of the department’s Special Investigation Unit that conducted the operation between 1 and 4 p.m. Saturday, netting nine arrests of would-be customers.

“There’s a market out there and we’re going to do what we have to do,” he said. And so they did.

Twenty-four-year-old Officer Kelly Aylward was the undercover decoy during the operation conducted in the downtown area, according to Carrow. The targets of this brilliantly conceived plan was to have an attractive female see if she could get men to want to have sex with her and be willing to pay for it.

Continue reading "North And South Of Boston, Sex Trade Stings Are In Full Swing" »

November 21, 2008

Boston Intoxicated Driver Said To Speed Through Massachusetts Town

Sean G., 20, of Roslindale (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) was out for a drive early Wednesday morning. Normally, that might not pose so much of a problem. However, this time was different.

You see, according to the police, the Defendant was drunk. Upon further investigation, he was apparently not even supposed to be driving the car in the first place.

However, the Defendant’s real problems began when the police took notice of the gray sedan in Holliston, Massachusetts.

According to Police Sgt. George Leurini, the Defendant was seen driving the sedan on Route 126 traveling over the posted speed limit. The Speed limit was 25 miles per hour – the Defendant was going 39 mph. Sgt. Leuini turned on his siren.

Apparently, this confused the Defendant as he neither stopped nor slowed down; he sped up. Now, instead of the 39 mph, he accelerated to 70 mph.

The police car gave chase.

Perhaps quizzical as to why 70 mph was not enough to satisfy the police, the Defendant kept accelerating until it became a high speed chase at speeds of 100 mph.

Continue reading "Boston Intoxicated Driver Said To Speed Through Massachusetts Town" »

November 14, 2008

Drunk Driving In Massachusetts – Three Stages Of The Criminal Justice Experience

As we head into another weekend…edging ever closer to the holiday season…a reminder about one of the more common criminal justice pitfalls which people tend to experience. Namely, drunk driving.

Many cases around the subject of Operating Under the Influence have hit the press this past week. Today’s daily blog looks at three of them, all three differing in their stage of the prosecution.

First, let’s look to Yarmouth, Massachusetts, the scene of an interesting arrest scene, particularly if you are a dog lover, Tuesday. Axel, the police department K-9 dog, was called upon to help locate an alleged drunk driver at the Foxwoods Condominiums in West Yarmouth .

Bryan C., 41, of Barnstable, (hereinafter, “Defendant 1”) is said to have crashed his 2001 Monte Carlo deep into the woods off Camp Street around 10 p.m. Tuesday. Police say he then fled the scene.

Strikes one and two.

When officers arrived they found the severely damaged car, but no driver. Police were told by a witness that the lone male driver had crawled out of the vehicle, grabbed an item and ran off.

Police brought in K-9 patrol officer Peter McClelland and his partner Axel to track the suspect. They initially found an opened and cold 12 pack of beer - with four remaining cans - on the side of the road about 200 yards from the crash scene. The track continued and led to the front door of a unit at the condominium complex.

Once found, Defendant 1 told officers he was "having a bad night" and admitted to driving the vehicle.

Strike three. Out.

Continue reading "Drunk Driving In Massachusetts – Three Stages Of The Criminal Justice Experience" »

November 7, 2008

South And North Of Boston Tales Of Drunk Driving And Providing Alcohol To Minors Come Home To Roost

Massachusetts just voted to change the way we handle the prosecution of possessing a small amount of marihuana. Meanwhile, alcohol still seems to be getting its share of publicity as well.

Two recent stories bring the subject of alcohol home.

No, literally….home.

For example, at approximately 4:30 a.m. this past Saturday morning, Park Street in Stoughton was the scene of a lot of excitement; a car crashed into one of its houses, causing a fire that is now said to have made the house structurally unsafe.

Donald M., 22 (hereinafter, “Defendant 1”) is said to have driven into the uninhabited home, police said, and charged with operating under the influence of liquor, operating a motor vehicle negligently so as to endanger and marked lanes violation.

Fortunately, the home had already been uninhabited.

“Why?”, you ask.

“Because a similar thing happened last year”, I answer. That’s right, the house had already sustained serious damage, including a gaping hole to its foundation, caused by a similar accident last year. Defendant 1’s accident simply added another gaping hole. And caused a fire. And pushed the safety of the structure over the edge of soundness.

Continue reading "South And North Of Boston Tales Of Drunk Driving And Providing Alcohol To Minors Come Home To Roost" »

October 22, 2008

Cousin Reveals Massachusetts Drunk Driver Leaving Scene And Attempting Fraud

We are now announcing a special “family plan” for the “Hey, I’ll Bet I Can Make This Situation Worse” club we have spoken so much of in this daily blog.

Lawrence, Massachusetts. July, 2008. A 1997 Honda Civic careens into a fence on Phillips Street. Eduard M., 19, (hereinafter, the “Defendant”), the driver, takes the unorthodox approach – he tells his passengers to follow him and they flee the scene. He then reports the car stolen.

It’s a good start toward individual membership. After all, what’s a simple car accident when you can have charges of leaving the scene and fraud added with very little additional effort?

Clinching this nomination, however, is the Defendant’s cousin, Jose, who then went back to the scene to retrieve his hat.

You see, Jose is a friendly guy and ended up talking about the situation with a resident of the house where the accident had occurred. He told the resident how the Defendant had been drunk, but that his auto insurance would cover damage to the fence.

Lawrence police are a friendly bunch too and one of their officers ended up engaged in the conversation with cousin Jose. So, Jose elaborated on the story. He told the officer that his cousin, the Defendant, was drunk and had a suspended driver's license, but still insisted on driving five other people home from a party on Kendall Street. Missing a turn at Dorchester and Phillips streets, the Defendant hit the fence instead.

Continue reading "Cousin Reveals Massachusetts Drunk Driver Leaving Scene And Attempting Fraud" »

October 17, 2008

Drunk Driver, Fifth Offense, Says Prostitute Caused The Accident

You know, I think prostitutes are getting a bad rap this week. Yesterday’s daily blog covered a young lady with a record for prostitution being arrest under…curious…circumstances. Today, we examine a case where a prostitute is blamed for something once again…and not for her chosen profession. It is unlikely to end the same way, though.

57-year old Leonard R. (hereinafter, the“Defendant”) had a little problem this past Sunday, apparently when he was returning home in Pittsfield. Well, he did not exactly drive to his home…he drove into his home. His speed is not indicated, but his Toyota Tundra is said to have destroyed a garage door and caused structural damage to the brick building.

According to Central Berkshire District Court records, he was driving with a revoked license. His license had been revoked because of previous drunk driving convictions.

Oh yes, he is also alleged to have been drunk at the time of the collision with his apartment building.

Well, he was now home, after all, so he left the nasty seen and went to his apartment. According to Pittsfield police, he was found "hiding in his bedroom closet".

Continue reading "Drunk Driver, Fifth Offense, Says Prostitute Caused The Accident" »

October 13, 2008

Massachusetts Trespassers, Thieves And Adventurers Face variety Of Criminal Charges West and South Of Boston

Today is Columbus Day. As we honor the adventurer who is celebrated as the man who discovered America (although other people were already living here at the time), I think it appropriate that we recognize other valiant efforts at similar discoveries. However, being that this is a daily Criminal Law blog, we unfortunately have to focus on a few not-so successful voyages.

It turns out to be easy, though; last week was not a particularly good week for voyagers to the other side of the law, especially south and west of Boston.

Let’s turn first to Tuesday in Warren, Massachusetts, where the police believe they have linked a suspect to three recent break-ins. This gentleman, Matthew W., 24, (hereinafter, “Defendant 1”), was captured thanks to his alleged intended victim – a 78-year-old woman who confronted him in her bedroom and chased him out the window.

Defendant 1 is currently being held at the Hampshire County House of Correction in Northampton, awaiting trial on charges out of Ware. Tuesday, he was arraigned at Western Worcester District Court in East Brookfield on nine counts related to three break-ins.

According to court documents, the intended not-so-helpless victim was inside her apartment in West Warren about 9:30 a.m. when she heard a voice yelling “Hello, Hello,” outside her bedroom window. She went to the window and saw a young man, who asked if she’d like him to mow her lawn. She declined and he asked her if she got out much.

Continue reading "Massachusetts Trespassers, Thieves And Adventurers Face variety Of Criminal Charges West and South Of Boston" »

October 10, 2008

Massachusetts Driver On Probation Faces Third Round Of Charges For Operating Under The Influence

David K., 38, of Hamilton, Massachusetts (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) is getting points for consistency – negative points. He has just been arrested for his third alleged occasion of driving under the influence. In fact, he also faces bonus points for violating probation because of the arrest. Currently, he is awaiting his final score as a guest of the Commonwealth.

The Defendant came to the attention of police when he was driving just after 2:00 a.m. on Bridge Street in Beverly. Unfortunately, the headlights on his pickup truck were not on. He was pulled over and, during questioning, the officer says he smelled alcohol and noticed that the driver seemed uncoordinated as he fumbled for the registration. When asked if he had been drinking, the Defendant showed the officer a prescription bottle of Trazadone, a painkiller he said he was taking because of surgery to his Achilles tendon two years ago. According to the police report, he also told the officer that he had taken two pills — twice the suggested dosage.

Digesting all of this, the officer checked the Defendant’s information and learned that the Defendant was not even supposed to be behind the wheel in the first place. In addition to a one-year license suspension because of two similar cases last year, his license had been revoked in December for four years by the Registry of Motor Vehicles, which deemed him a habitual offender for some reason.

You see, last year, the Defendant was arrested twice in less than a month for impaired driving. On August 4, 2007, he was charged with drunken driving after sideswiping another driver on Route 128 in Danvers, forcing the other driver off the road, according to a police report. He registered a .30 on a Breathalyzer test that time and denied that an accident occurred, despite a mirror hanging off the other driver’s car and other damage.

A few weeks later, on August 30, 2007, he was driving near the intersection of Bridge and River streets when he turned a corner and crashed into the side of a car that was stopped for a stop sign, injuring one of the two young children in the back seat, according to a police report. When the police came, they saw that the Defendant, who was not supposed to be driving because of the earlier arrest, was “lethargic” and slow to respond. He explained that he had taken both Ativan and Torpol that morning. Police believe he had also taken twice the recommended dose, according to the report.

In October, 2007, Judge Robert Brennan ordered the Defendant to serve 90 days of a 2 1/2 year jail term for both cases, with the balance suspended for two years. During those two years, of course, he would be on probation.

You guessed it…that means that the new arrest violates his probation and the Defendant could now be facing another 27 months in Middleton Jail if he is found to have violated his probation. This would be on top of any additional punishment for the new charges.

The Defendant makes his next court appearance on Oct. 16th; this time the Commonwealth will be providing his transportation.

Sam’s take:

I am sure you already know that you are not supposed to drive while intoxicated. I’ll bet you even know that it is illegal to drive when your license is suspended or revoked. However, here is something that you may not know…at least today’s Defendant did not seem to know…you are not supposed to drive if you are impaired by medication, even if it is legally prescribed.

The Bridge Street Bomber seemed to think that by showing the police that he was simply under the influence of medication would somehow solve the problem of his fumbling with his registration and odor of alcohol. The “No, I’m not drunk…just under the influence of this other little beauty” approach will not, and did not, help the situation. Neither does explaining how you took a double dosage…especially when you seem to have a history of doing that.

Years ago, people did not take drunk driving very seriously. It is widely understood that this has changed in a big way. However, there are still people who think that driving without a valid license is not that big a deal. It is. Aside from being a crime in itself, driving when your license is not valid sends a message to the court that its rulings do not particularly matter to you. Judges tend to frown upon that.

And now a word about being on probation. “On probation” is not a legal term for “Care Free”. Failing to follow the department of probation’s directives means a violation of probation. A violation usually means jail. When the violation is a new arrest, the result is usually jail before the new case is even resolved. That’s right…while you are still presumed innocent of the new charges.

While on probation, you are in a state of diminished rights. You are free so long as you comply with your probation officer. You also have fewer of the safeguards afforded you when facing a regular criminal charge. While there is a hearing, there is no full-blown trial. The issue to be decided is not whether you are guilty of the new offense. It is whether you violated probation.

Again, getting re-arrested is a violation of probation.

If you have any question about your rights while on probation or what does and does not constitute operating under the influence, you should contact an experienced criminal defense attorney. Do not guess. Do not assume. And, if your ability to drive is compromised, do not drive.

Have a good and law-abiding weekend!

The full article of this story can be found at :
http://www.salemnews.com/punews/local_story_283001115.html

October 6, 2008

Boston Driver Creates New Lane And Chaos On Route 93, Adding Multiple Charges To Operating Under the Influence

It would seem that some people are never satisfied. Now that “The Big Dig” is completed, one particular driver was unhappy with the lanes created by the extensive project. Her solution was apparently to create a “speedy-reverse lane”.

Siobhan H, 21 years of age and Norwood of residence (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) was in court this past Friday facing various charges for her ingenuity. She had come to the attention of police when calls were received of a driver traveling on the wrong side of the highway at the Hanover exit on Route 3. She continued in her special lane, traveling almost 20 miles in the wrong direction on I-93 Southbound all the way to Dorchester in her 1998 Chevrolet Malibu. She drove at speeds over 100 miles per hour, according to the authorities.

When the police tried to stop her, she did what one would expect she would do; she tried to out-drive them. During the chase, the Defendant slammed into one car and jersey barriers. Finally, the police blew out her tires through use of “stop sticks”.

While the car chase, and the existence of her individualized lane, had now ended, the Defendant, was not quite ready to call it a day. So, she took off on foot into nearby woods. However, the inevitable did occur. She was found by state troopers and the K-9 section near the Neponset River.

Based upon keen observation of the Defendant’s demeanor and actions, the officers administered a field sobriety test and a portable breath test. She apparently consented. It was a shock to none that she failed the tests. Sources said Her blood-alcohol level was twice the legal limit.

According to prosecutors, discussion with the police further reflected her…unique… attitude.

The officer told her, "You are lucky you didn't kill someone"

Her response was "Yeah, but I didn't."

Ever seeing the glass half-full, she posted bail Friday evening. She now awaits a Pretrial Hearing.

Sam’s take:

You know, there are some days when this daily blog just seems to write itself.

Needless to say, while creativity is usually appreciated in this world, there are limits. You do not get to create your own high speed lanes going the wrong direction on highways. You do not need me to tell you that it is dangerous and illegal…in the extreme. You also know that driving drunk is similarly frowned upon.

Once again we have a defendant who seems to be a devoted member of the “Hey, I’ll Bet I Can Make This Worse” club. Aside from the obvious original crime which risked the lives of herself and everyone else on Routes 3 and 93, she tried to outrace the police while driving. She tried to outrun the police on foot. She had the absolute need to open her mouth while being arrested, giving the prosecutor even more evidence to use against her to the judge and/or jury.

She also, by the way, showed the poor judgment to agree to both field sobriety tests and the breathalyzer. While nothing has yet been proven beyond a reasonable doubt, let’s stretch our imaginations and consider the possibility that she had been drinking…to whatever state of inebriation. She knows she just drove like a crazy person and then led the police on a chase that ended in their popping her tires after she had already hit one car and the jersey barrier. What could she hope to prove by way of the two tests?

In Massachusetts, one loses one’s license for a time if the tests are refused. Did she really think that her license was not already about to be, at least, suspended? Giving new meaning to the term “dangerous driver”, combined with any other suspicion that she had been drinking was going to cost her the license for a time. Now, she has done her very best to ensure that it is for the longest time possible. Of course, she will not be needing to drive too much if confined to the local jail or state prison for the variety of charges she will now face.

Once again, if the police pull you over…go over. Particularly if you know you have been drinking, politely refuse the tests. Do not indulge the desire for clever repartee with the officers. Chances are, if you may be drunk, it will not be so clever.

Simple wisdom here, folks. Be quiet. Comply. Get a lawyer…fast.


Samuel Goldberg is the senior criminal defense attorney at the firm of Altman & Altman, P.C. A former prosecutor in New York, he has worked as a defense attorney in Boston over 18 years. He frequently provides legal analysis on radio and television, appearing on outlets such as the Fox News Channel, Court TV, MSNBC and The BBC Network

The full article of this story can be found at http://www1.whdh.com/news/articles/local/BO90313/

September 17, 2008

Arrest Warrant Inspires Massachusetts Driver To Make As Many Mistakes As Possible During Traffic Stop

Some people have not been taking this blog to heart and so apparently did not believe that it was not good to take a bad situation with law enforcement and make it worse. Now, 19-year-old Falmouth resident, Tevis Yarmala, faces multiple charges after he allegedly struck and tried to stab a Falmouth police officer in the face with a stick during a traffic stop last week.

Mr. Yarmala is alleged to have run a red light. First strike. Observing this, Patrolman Christopher Bartolomei , according to police reports, pulled the vehicle over. Mr. Yarmala is said to have greeted the officer by name. Second strike. When the patrolman “detected” the odor of burnt marijuana and asked about it, Mr. Yarmala admitted to smoking marijuana at a friend's house. Third strike.

In this particular game…not out yet.

Mr. Yarmala was then ordered out of the car. His response was apparently to strike Officer Bartolomei in the head with his elbow when Officer Bartolomei attempted to remove a plastic bag containing marijuana from Mr. Yarmala's pocket. A struggle ensued in which Mr. Yarmala is said to have made "moans and groans as if he were possessed."

Strike out.

A passing motorist came to the officer’s assistance and the two were able to subdue Yarmala sufficiently so that he could be handcuffed with his hands in front of him. Mr. Yarmala, who was not ready to give up the game, is reported to have reached above his head, grab a four inch stick and attempt to stab Officer Bartolomei in the face. When additional police arrived, the Commonwealth’s newest guest was handcuffed with his hands behind his back and shackled. Ever the optimist, he continued to put up a struggle.

But it was “game over”.

During the fight, Mr. Yarmala was apparently able to successfully grab the bag, rip it and scatter some of the contents on the grass. A portion of the marijuana that had been scattered was recovered. It, along with portion still in the bag, totaled 60 grams.


Officer Bartolomei injured his knee during the fight when he crashed through a stone wall. He was treated at Falmouth Hospital and told that he may have sustained ligament damage.


Mr. Yarmala, aka Defendant, was charged with possession of a class D substance, possession of a class D substance with intent to distribute, violating drug laws near school or park, assault and battery on a police officer, assault with a dangerous weapon, disorderly conduct and several traffic violations. An arrest warrant had already been in force at the time of his arrest, the result of an OUI and leaving the scene of an accident on August 28th.


Sam’s take:

Well, at least Mr. Yarmala had more to be afraid of than simply getting a traffic ticket given the outstanding arrest warrant. However, as discussed in earlier blogs, all he accomplished was to make a bad situation infinitely worse. The fact is, even if there is a warrant out for your arrest, engaging the officer in a struggle is going to make your plight much, much worse. And, by the way, if you are in mid-struggle with the solo police officer…when a bunch of his fellow officers show up…your chances at success do not increase, they decrease. And when you are cuffed and shackled? It is a strong sign that you are probably not going to win the struggle. As they say in “Star Trek”, “Resistance is futile”.

Actually, Mr. Yarmala’s mistakes began long before last week. First of all, leaving the scene of an accident in which there was damage is a crime in itself and is seldom successful. He apparently was aware that there was an arrest warrant out for him. I cannot tell you how often I meet a client who was aware they had such a warrant, but thought they could somehow outlive it without having to answer to it. These meetings often take place in jail, by the way. So far, at least in my more than twenty years of experience in the Criminal Justice Trenches, this has not been a gamble that pays off. Things get much worse if you do not address the warrant yourself voluntarily before the good folks in blue show up at your door. So, if there is a warrant out for your arrest, deal with it before it catches up with you.

It was a mistake for “You Can’t Catch Me” Yarmala to go through the red light or to drive after smoking marihuana . Those are really so obvious they are barely worth mentioning. So, let’s go to the next stop (no pun intended). Especially if you are driving around with an arrest warrant dangling over your head, the wiser course is to not have some leftover drugs in your pocket. If pulled over under these circumstances, it is not the best of judgment to be a wise-guy and happily greet the officer by name. And if you found these things to difficult to follow…you really do not want to answer happy little questions like if you had been smoking marihuana. There is that whole right to remain silent and get a lawyer thing, remember?

And then there is that attacking of the police officers problem. Bad idea. You will not win. The only rewards you can hope for are more charges and greater injuries.

By the way, assuming he was not merely trying to fit in some planting, Slugger Yarmala’s attempts to sprinkle out the marihuana was really a fool’s errand. First of all, as discussed in earlier blogs, the drugs do not have to be found physically on you for you to be successfully prosecuted for them. Even if they did, if they had already been observed in your pocket, dumping them in front of the officer does not usually change history.

So, let’s review the lessons of today’s daily blog:

1. If you have an accident causing property or physical damage, do not simply leave;
2. If there is a warrant out for your arrest, get an attorney and deal with it immediately, if not sooner;
3. Do not drive stoned or drunk and do not carry your stash around with you while out for a drive;
4. Do not engage the officer who stops you in clever repartee like calling him or her by name or telling them that you just smoked pot. Answer the questions you have to answer (as in give your license and registration) and wait for a lawyer to assist you;
5. Do not attack, fight, struggle with, try to kill, attempt to outrun, drive over, stab, dump drugs in front of, or even argue with the officer. Do what you are told and minimize damage; and finally,
6. Read this daily blog and take its lessons to heart!

The full article of this story can be found at :
http://www.wickedlocal.com/falmouth/archive/x332631811/Falmouth-traffic-stop-results-in-scuffle-multiple-charges

September 3, 2008

Massachusetts State Police Recover Drug Stash After Car Chase And Violent Arrest

Last Thursday night, two gentlemen in Taunton learned that sometimes it is better to quietly accept a motor vehicle citation than to protest, flee and fight, thereby adding a few felony charges to the experience.

Enterprise News reports that just before 5 p.m. two state troopers spotted an early-model Infiniti G20 with a defective brake light and a sticker indicating that it had failed an inspection on Route 44. They activated their flashing lights and the driver, Brian Lacombe, 20, pulled into the parking lot of KFC restaurant on Route 44 and stopped. However, as the officers left their cruisers to approach on foot, Lacombe apparently had a change of heart and allegedly sped away heading east on Route 44.
And so the chase began.

During the chase, police said, they observed a plastic baggie — later retrieved and determined to contain a Class B drug — being tossed out of a window of the Infiniti into the road near Friendly’s Restaurant in Raynham.

The police chase continued and Lacombe, who reportedly drove through a red light at a busy intersection, made a hard U-turn across the highway island. He then pulled into the Chili’s parking lot, made another U-turn and headed west on Route 44 back into Taunton, racing through red lights in the process, police said. The chase almost ended at the intersection of Oak and Wales streets when Lacombe allegedly crashed into a 1999 Honda Civic driven by a pizza delivery driver, who police said was not injured. Not to be discouraged, Lacombe then made another U-turn. However, a block later, the damaged Infiniti pulled into the driveway of 79 Wales St. Police said Lacombe and his passenger, Julius Nettles, 23, jumped out and began to run away.
Nettles was reportedly quickly apprehended without incident, but Lacombe, ever the optimist, ran through several yards and jumped some fences in an attempt to evade capture. This part of the chase did not last as long, however, and he was apprehended at Oak Street and Hern Avenue, but not before engaging in “a brief but violent struggle” with officers, according to state police spokesman Trooper Thomas Murphy.

Lacombe was treated at the scene for minor injuries before being transported to state police barracks to be booked.

Lacombe was charged with possession with intent to distribute a Class B drug, possession of a Class D drug, failing to stop for police, reckless operation of a motor vehicle, driving with a suspended license, marked lanes violation, driving with a defective brake light, failing to obey both a stop sign and red light, speeding, failing to signal, leaving the scene of an accident with property damage resulting and resisting arrest.

His passenger, Nettles, faces charges of possession with intent to distribute a Class B drug and possession of a Class D drug.

Sam’s take:

Clearly, it is a bad idea to drive when one does not have a valid license. It is also a good idea to make sure the equipment on your motor vehicle is working. Having made these errors in judgment, however, it is usually best not to increase the severity of the situation one thousandfold as did Mr. Lacombe. Most likely, had he simply cooperated with the car stop, he would have received a summons for the defective equipment and driving with a suspended license. His passenger would then have been given the responsibility of driving the vehicle (assuming he had a valid license). One would imagine that this would have been bad enough and Lacombe would get an attorney and defend against the relatively minor charges.

It is seldom a good idea to lead the police in a chase. First of all, they tend to win. Second, property damage, physical injury and even death (potentially yours) can easily result. Further, a foot chase is generally even less successful than the car chase. Finally, any type of violent confrontation with the police, even if merely questioning their authority during a stop, is a contest usually won by law enforcement both at the scene….and later….in the courthouse. For example, notice who needed to get treated for injuries before being transported.

According to this report, Lacombe apparently did not want the police to discover the drugs he had in the car. However, had he simply accepted the citation for the defective equipment and suspended license, there would have been no basis for a car search, especially since his passenger would have been able to drive the car home. By the way, throwing the drugs out the window is not generally an effective means of sidestepping prosecution. There are a number of legal theories which can serve to link one with contraband which is not physically on one’s person.
The only manner of non-cooperation that is usually wise in a police confrontation is not making statements, other than identification information, and, most importantly, getting a lawyer as soon as possible!

The full article of this story can be found at
http://www.enterprisenews.com/news/x1886920440/Car-chase-leads-to-drug-arrests-in-Taunton

September 2, 2008

Massachusetts Drunk Driver Charged With North Shore Pedicab Accident And Leaving The Scene

The pre-Labor Day Weekend push of commercials warning against operating under the influence did not prevent the collision between an automobile and a pedicab just before the weekend, according to a story published by the Salem News.

According to the article, a 20 year old female struck the pedicab just after midnight on Washington Street in downtown Salem. According to the police, she stopped “for a brief moment” and then drove around the tipped-over pedicab and then left the scene. The pedicab’s driver, Anthony Taurasi III, reportedly chased the motor vehicle up the road before collapsing on the ground. Mr. Taurasi and one of his passengers were then brought to the hospital. During his brief chase, however, he was able to view a partial license plate.

Given the license plate number, police said they found Rose Barry of Beverly driving on Highland Avenue with her hazard lights on. However, when the police turned on their blue lights and sirens, she refused to stop "made an abrupt right turn into the rear of 84 Highland Ave. and then attempted to go between a space in the guardrail."
Ms. Barry was immediately arrested and charged with leaving the scene of an accident with personal injury. More charges followed as police took her back to the police station, where she reportedly blew alcohol levels of 0.12 and 0.13. State law says drivers of legal drinking age, 21, are drunk at levels of 0.08 or above. She was also charged with leaving the scene of an accident with property damage, failure to stop for police, failure to yield and operating under the influence of alcohol.
Taurasi said he spent the night in the emergency room. He said one of his passengers, a 15-year-old girl, had bruised ribs. The other passenger, a 22-year-old Peabody man, refused medical treatment.

Barry's passenger, whose 20th birthday was Thursday, got a ride home through her father.

Barry remained a guest of the Commonwealth.

Sam’s take:
Other than the first major mistake of the evening Ms. Barry made (namely driving drunk), she successfully made matters worse for herself at each decision after the accident. Leaving the scene after an accident (which causes either property damage, personal injury or both) is a crime in itself. Further, while the law provides for what some consider rather gentle treatment for a first time offender of OUI, leaving the scene and taking the police on a merry chase is likely to eliminate the possibility of “getting a break”. Further, knowing that she had been drinking, she voluntarily took the breathalyzer test, which she had the right not to do. True, the refusal to take the test in Massachusetts means a temporary loss of license, but helping the Commonwealth prove she was under the influence does not improve her chances of keeping her license…in fact, she will lose her license for a longer time.

It is not clear whether Ms. Barry made any statements to the police, but it would appear consistent if she had. In other words, that would have been another big mistake. Many people think that they can somehow “talk themselves” out of a bad situation such as this. In these types of cases, the most common statement is that the driver “only had two drinks”. Such a statement is hardly helpful as (1) it is seldom believed and (2) it really does not matter. If the police believe they have probable cause to arrest you for driving under the influence, they will arrest you for operating under the influence. Generally, this decision is made without the driver helping them with a confession. They usually appreciate the help, though, and award the driver with a free trip and overnight stay behind bars.

Circumstances such as these also bring other legal problems beyond the actual criminal prosecution. For example, there is likely to be one or more personal injury lawsuits against the driver (and the owner of the vehicle if it is not her) by the various passengers.

At Altman & Altman LLP, now located on the North Shore, Cambridge and Boston, Massachusetts, our successful criminal and civil defense lawyers have more than 50 years combined experience, including previous experience as prosecutors, and take the time necessary to gather all the facts of your case and advise your of your rights and your defense options. If you find yourself being accused of operating under the influence, or any related crime, act today to see if we can help you. There is no charge for the initial consultation.


The full article of this story can be found at
http://www.salemnews.com/punews/local_story_242235151.html

Samuel Goldberg is the senior criminal defense attorney at the firm of Altman & Altman, P.C. A former prosecutor in New York, he has worked as a defense attorney in Boston over 18 years. He frequently provides legal analysis on radio and television, appearing on outlets such as the Fox News Channel, Court TV, MSNBC and The BBC Network


August 20, 2008

Milton Mother Arrested for Operating Under the Influence of Alcohol

In Massachusetts, Denise Egerton, a 41-year-old Milton mother, was arrested and charged with operating under the influence of alcohol, driving without a license, and speeding. Egerton had been driving the car that collided with a van in Dorchester on Friday, close to the intersection of Woodrow and Blue Hill Avenues. The van was thrown airborne before overturning and than van’s driver was taken to the hospital.

Egerton told police that the van had tried crossing in front of her car to make a left turn. Witnesses accuse Egerton of speeding.

At the accident scene, police had Egerton take a field sobriety test, which she did not pass. Her two children, ages 1 and 4, were in the car with her when the crash happened. They were taken to Boston Medical Center after the crash and later placed in the care of the Department of Social Service.

Field Sobriety Tests
Field sobriety tests can be administered at the scene to determine whether a driver has been driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs.

Kinds of Field Sobriety Tests Include:

• Touching one’s nose with a finger
• Walking a straight line
• Counting while standing on one foot
• Reciting the alphabet

In many cases, the results of a field sobriety test is among the primary evidence used to charge a driver with OUI. It is important to note, however, that these tests do not always accurately reflect whether someone was driving drunk. Overweight people and people with leg problems or balance problems may experience difficulty passing these tests when they are sober.
Mother arrested after collision with van, Boston.com, August 16, 2008


Related Web Resources:

Field Sobriety Tests

DUI and DWI, DMV.org

Continue reading "Milton Mother Arrested for Operating Under the Influence of Alcohol " »

July 29, 2008

Police Say Actor Shia LaBeouf May Not Have Caused Injury Crash Involving Drunk Driving

A spokesperson for the Sheriff’s Department in Los Angeles County says actor Shia LaBeouf may not have caused the drunk driving-related injury accident on July 27 in West Hollywood, California. The accident occurred around 2:30 am.

LaBeouf, who was arrested for DUI, has had to undergo surgery to repair an injury he sustained in his left hand. The woman riding with him and the woman driving the other vehicle were also injured. Both women sustained minor injuries.

LaBeouf has yet to be arraigned on the DUI charge. Now, however, there is evidence to indicate that the accident may have happened because the other driver ran a red light before striking LaBeuof’s truck, which rolled over during the accident.

If you have been arrested for driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs in Massachusetts, it is important that you speak with a Boston, Massachusetts DUI lawyer right away. An experienced DUI attorney will know how to handle the charges against you and can investigate your case to determine whether there is evidence showing that the criminal charges against you should be dropped or reduced.

For example, the charge and penalties will be different depending on whether this is your first or a subsequent DUI offense. The penalties are more severe if someone other than the alleged drunk driver suffered serious injuries in a DUI crash. In Massachusetts, an arrest for DUI that causes serious physical injuries can lead to up to 10 years in prison.

Shia LaBeouf might not have caused collision, Sheriff's Department says, Los Angeles Times, July 29, 2008

Actor Shia LaBeouf arrested, injured in drunk driving crash, AFP, July 28, 2008


Related Web Resources:

Shia LaBeouf

Massachusetts Law About Drunk Driving, Massachusetts Trial Court Law Libraries

Continue reading "Police Say Actor Shia LaBeouf May Not Have Caused Injury Crash Involving Drunk Driving" »

April 22, 2008

Gloucester Woman Involved in Head-On Car Crash with Sandra Bullock in Massachusetts Pleads Not Guilty

The Gloucester woman charged with operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of intoxicating liquor and failure to stay in a marked lane when her car struck the SUV carrying movie star Sandra Bullock has pled not guilty.

Lucile P. Gatchell entered her not guilty plea during her arraignment today in Gloucester District Court. She was released without bail.

No one was injured in the Massachusetts car accident, which occurred on Friday. Bullock had just finished filming a scene from her latest movie "The Proposal" in Rockport before the accident happened. The actress, her husband Jessie James, and the driver of their sport utility vehicle were not injured in the auto collision.

According to the police report, Gatchell failed four field sobriety tests and her blood alcohol level registered over twice the legal limit at 2.0. Kevin Mackey, the arresting police officer, reported smelling alcohol on the 64-year-old woman’s breath. He also said that she slurred her speech and her eyes were glassy and bloodshot.

If you have been arrested or charged with operating your vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs, one of our Boston, Massachusetts OUI/DWI/DUI attorneys would be happy to discuss your case with you.

Our Gloucester drunk driving lawyers know how to determine the accuracy of your field sobriety test or whether law enforcement officers followed the proper procedures when apprehending you for allegedly driving drunk. There may be a number of reasons why the evidence that police have against you is inadmissible.

If you plead or are found guilty for drunk driving in Massachusetts, this will be noted on your driving record permanently. This could affect your driving privileges even if you live in another state.

Woman pleads not guilty to drunken driving in accident with Sandra Bullock, Boston.com, April 22, 2008

Actress Bullock unharmed in Gloucester car crash, Boston.com, April 19, 2008


Related Web Resources:

DUI & DWI, DMV.Org

Massachusetts Laws About Drunk Driving, Massachusetts Trial Court Law Libraries

Continue reading "Gloucester Woman Involved in Head-On Car Crash with Sandra Bullock in Massachusetts Pleads Not Guilty " »

November 1, 2007

Former Prison Break Star Lane Garrison To Serve 40 Months In Prison For Teen’s DUI Death

Ex-Prison Break Star Lane Garrison will serve 3 years and 4 months in a California prison in the DUI car accident death of a California teenager.

Garrison, 27, pleaded guilty to one count of vehicular manslaughter without gross negligence, a misdemeanor of providing alcohol to a minor, and one count of driving under the influence with a BAC level of .15 or higher.

Garrison had been driving under the influence of cocaine and alcohol in December 20067 when he crashed his 2001 Land Rover into a tree. Vahagn Setian, a 17-year-old student from Beverly Hills High and a passenger in the Land Rover, died in the accident. Two 15-year-old girls, also riding in the car, sustained injuries.

The actor’s BAC level was .20, which is twice as much as the legal driving limit in California. He also had cocaine in his system at the time of the crash.

Garrison met the teenagers at a grocery store and accompanied them to a party where he allegedly drank alcohol with minors and then went back to the store for more alcohol.

Being convicted of homicide while driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs in any US state is a very serious matter.

In Massachusetts, the Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) level is .08. Under Vehicular Homicide Law:

Vehicular Homicide While Operating Under the Influence of Alcohol or Other Drugs and While Operating To Endanger: Mandatory minimum 2 ½ years and up to 15 years in state prison or mandatory minimum 1 year and up to 2 ½ years in jail; plus fines and loss of license

Vehicular Homicide While Operating Under the Influence of Alcohol or Other Drugs or While Operating To Endanger: Mandatory minimum 30 days and up to 2 1/2 years in jail; plus fines and loss of license.

Actor Lane Garrison gets 40 months in jail for crash that killed teen, LA Times.com, October 31, 2007

Ex-'Prison Break' actor gets 40 months, CNN.com, October 31, 2007

Homicide, Mass.gov


Related Web Resource:

Lane Garrison News Stories, TV.com

Continue reading "Former Prison Break Star Lane Garrison To Serve 40 Months In Prison For Teen’s DUI Death" »

October 10, 2007

Actor Kiefer Sutherland Pleads No Contest to Drunk Driving Charges

TV actor Kiefer Sutherland has pleaded no contest to charges of drunk driving. The star of the TV show “24” will start serving a 48-day jail sentence in December when his show goes on a production break.

As part of his plea deal, Sutherland 18 days of those 48 days are for violating his probation for an unrelated drunk driving arrest in 2004. 30 days are for driving with a blood-alcohol level higher than California’s .08% limit. Sutherland also has been ordered to take part in alcohol-therapy sessions every week for six month, as well as sign up for an 18-month alcohol education course. . A related, misdemeanor DUI charge was dropped.

The TV actor is on probation for five years. He faces driving suspension and has to pay fines.

Sutherland will serve the 18-day part of his sentence beginning December 21. He has until July 28 to serve the last 30 days. The terms of the plea agreement allow him to serve time in jail in a manner that will not interrupt the show “24”’s shooting schedule. Sutherland’s representatives say he struck this deal with prosecutors because he did not want production to shut down while he was on trial or served time in jail—possibly affecting the livelihoods of the production members and other actors on the show.

“No Contest” Plea
A “plea” is the response of a defendant to criminal charges made against him or her. A defendant usually gives the plea during an arraignment right after the prosecution formally charges the defendant with the crime(s). A defendant can plea “guilty”, “not guilty,” and “no contest.”

A “no contest” plea means that defendant is formally accepting the punishments for the charges but is not officially acknowledging guilt. Pleading “no contest” is inadmissible as evidence of guilt if there is a related civil lawsuit, which can be a benefit to the defendant.

A “no contest” plea differs from a “guilty” plea. The defendant that pleads guilty is admitting that he or she is guilty of the charges.

“No contest’ and “guilty” pleas are often accompanied by a plea bargain. A plea bargain usually allows a defendant to receive a less severe sentence or have certain charges dropped. A plea bargain also minimizes the financial costs and publicity fallout from a criminal case—the latter of these two can be very important if the defendant is a celebrity, politician, or another famous figure. A plea bargain allows a defendant to avoid the stigma and unwanted scrutiny of a trial, as well as the uncertainty of the outcome.

Sutherland Pleads No Contest in DUI Case, AP, October 9, 2007

Related Web Resources:

Kiefer Sutherland charged with drunk driving, Los Angeles Times, September 28, 2007

Massachusetts Law about Drunk Driving

Continue reading "Actor Kiefer Sutherland Pleads No Contest to Drunk Driving Charges" »

August 24, 2007

Lindsay Lohan To Serve One Day In Jail After Reaching Plea Agreement on Misdemeanor Drunk Driving and Cocaine Charges

Movie star Lindsay Lohan will serve 10 days of community service, complete a drug treatment program, and serve one day in jail after reaching a plea deal on charges of drunken driving and driving under the influence of cocaine. As part of her deal, she will complete an 18-month alcohol education program and be on probation for 36 months.

The actress had initially been sentenced to 96 hours in jail. Her jail time was then lowered to 90 hours because of the time she served during her arrest.

Lohan issued a statement admitting that she was addicted to drugs and alcohol and was taking responsibility for breaking the law by pleading guilty to the charges made against her.

Earlier Thursday, she was charged with seven misdemeanors connected to two drunk driving arrests over the past four months. Prosecutors did not file more serious felony drug charges because they say there wasn’t enough drugs on her to do so.

Lohan pleaded guilty to two counts of being under the influence of cocaine. She also pleaded no contest to one count of reckless driving and two counts of driving with a blood-alcohol level higher than .08%. The two counts of DUI were dropped.

The movie star was arrested in Santa Monica, California on July 24 and in Beverly Hills on May 26. She tested below the .05 grams necessary to be charged with a felony drug crime both times. She entered rehab after both arrests.

OUI in Massachusetts
In Massachusetts, OUI—operating under the influence—is the charge given to someone who has been operating a motor vehicle under the influence of drugs or alcohol. A person can be charged for OUI if prosecutors can prove that the defendant’s ability to operate a car was impaired by driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs. Field sobriety test results and whether a motor vehicle accident occurred are some of the factors that are taken into consideration. The suspect can also be charged with OUI under the “per se” theory, which factors in the blood alcohol test (a result of .08% or more) and the arresting officers' observations.

The penalties for OUI convictions in Massachusetts:

• 1st Conviction: 2 ½ years maximum jail sentence, license suspension for 1 year, and an up to $5,000 maximum fine
• 2nd Conviction: 2 ½ years maximum jail sentence, license suspension for 2 years, and an up to $10,000 maximum fine
• 3rd Conviction: 5 years maximum jail sentence, license suspension for 8 years, and an up to $15,000 maximum fine
• 4th Conviction: 5 years maximum jail sentence, license suspension for 10 years, and an up to $25,000 maximum fine
• 5th Conviction: 5 years maximum jail sentence, license permanently revoked, and an up to $50,000 maximum fine

Pleading guilty to or being convicted of an OUI charge will stay permanently on your record in Massachusetts.

Lindsay Lohan to serve 1 day in jail in plea bargain, CNN.com, August 24, 2007

Lindsay Lohan Gets Jail in DUI Cases, People.com, August 23, 2007


Related Web Resources:

Read the Complaint from Lindsay Lohan's May 26 Arrest

Massachusetts OUI Basics, Massachusetts DMV.org

Continue reading "Lindsay Lohan To Serve One Day In Jail After Reaching Plea Agreement on Misdemeanor Drunk Driving and Cocaine Charges" »