Boston Criminal Lawyer Blog

The state Supreme Judicial Court will likely issue a ruling in the next few weeks on Christopher McCowen’s appeal to have his Massachusetts murder and rape convictions in the slaying of fashion writer Christa Worthington overturned. McCowen’s criminal defense team is arguing that it was wrong to allow the a substitute pathologist to testify about findings in an autopsy that another doctor had performed and they are now citing a recent SJC ruling that overturned the murder conviction of Eric J. Durand for the fatal beating of Brendon Camara, his girlfriend’s 4-year-old son, on similar grounds.

McCowen was convicted in 2006 for Worthington’s Truro, Massachusetts rape and murder. The 46-year-old Vassar-educated writer and Truro resident was found stabbed to death in her home in January 2002. Her 2 ½ year old daughter was with her, unharmed but hugging her mom’s body and smeared in blood.

In 2005, Police charged McCowen, who was the trash collector for Worthington’s residence, with the slaying. Even though McCowen agreed to let police test his DNA soon after the murder, it would be two years before the authorities would collect his DNA and another year before it was matched to the crime.

A little over a year after McCowen’s 2006 conviction for Massachusetts murder and rape, Barnstable Superior Court Judge Gary A. Nickerson held a public hearing during which time he interviewed jury members about allegations of racial bias. McCowen is black. The allegations formed the basis for McCowen’s criminal defense lawyer's request for a new trial, but the judge would go on to turn down the motion. McCowen’s Massachusetts criminal defense attorneys have challenged this ruling.

Cape and Islands prosecutor Julia K. Holler, who represented the state in McCowen’s appeal, says that while it was wrong for a pathologist other than the one that conducted the autopsy to testify in McCowen’s criminal case, because McCowen’s criminal defense lawyer did not object to a criminal trial the state’s highest court has to limit its review to whether the testimony created a “substantial likelihood of a miscarriage of justice." This is a higher legal standard than what was applied to Durand’s appeal and one which Holler claims that McCowen’s conviction case does not meet.

SJC ruling hovers over 2002 Cape slaying case, Boston.com, August 28, 2010

Conviction reversed in Mass. boy’s beating death, Boston Herald, August 20, 2010

SJC hears Christopher McCowen appeal, Cape Cod Online, May 7, 2010

Related Web Resources:
The General Laws of Massachusetts

Murder on the Cape: A tale of love and death, Boston.com, January 20, 2002

Continue reading "SJC Ruling Could Overturn Christopher McCowen’s Convictions for Massachusetts Rape and Murder in Slaying of Christa Worthington" »

Sex cases are a funny thing. That is, “funny” as in “strange”. In a country wherein we say that we prize the presumption of innocence, we really don’t act like we like said presumption very much.

Currently, I am handling a high profile case about child pornography. Already, the press is interested. This, of course, is natural and is the job of the media. However, I am troubled not by the fact that it is newsworthy, but the reaction of people. Any passer-by who is questioned about the matter seems to have already formulated the verdict of “guilty”. People are shocked that “this has happened”, except that a man's good deeds have been completely disregarded because of the new accusations. Other than that, nothing else has been proven to have “happened”.

What is even more troubling is the aftermath.

I can still locate articles from 2008 when another client of mine was arrested and charged with rape involving a child. People were interested then. Well, for the last two years, we fought against the “assumption of guilt” while trying to remind everybody else that a “presumption of innocence” was rumored to still exist. Finally, two years later, my client was completely exonerated…as in “Not Guilty”. Out of curiosity last night, I cruised the internet to find mention of the fact that my client, who attempts to resurrect his life now that he has been acquitted, has been found not guilty.

Big surprise – nary a whisper.

Continue reading "Another Clergy Sex Crimes Case Inspires Reflections On Years Of Boston Criminal Defense" »

The criminal trial of Vernon Thompson on two counts of Massachusetts rape is now under way. Thompson, 40 is accused of sexually assaulting a Newton teenager while he was a psychiatric patient at Lemuel Shattuck Hospital in Jamaica Plain in 2008.

He is accused of taking the girl, then 14, to an area of the hospital where there were no security cameras and sexually assaulting her. His Boston criminal defense lawyer is asking jurors to remember that the defendant was a mental health patient when the allegedMassachusetts sexual crime happened. She also noted that because of his diminished mental capacity, he was incapable of understanding his actions or conforming to the law.

Diminished Mental Capacity Defense
Due to mental illness, a psychological disorder, or other health issues, some people who’ve committed a crimes lack the capacity to understand that their actions constituted a criminal act. Evidence of diminished capacity can be presented to a jury as part of the defense as they consider whether to find a defendant guilty or not guilty of a crime.

Massachusetts is zealous when it comes to pursuing people charged with sexual crimes and it is important that you are represented by a Boston criminal defense lawyer that can secure the best outcome possible for your case. A conviction as a sex offender can land you in prison for years, place you on the Massachusetts sex offender registry for life, and likely have serious repercussions on your career and personal life.

Girl, 16, testifies at rape case, Boston.com, July 14, 2010

Hospital Rape Case To Begin, WCVB, July 6, 2010

Continue reading "Psychiatric Patient on Trial for Boston Rape Has Diminished Mental Capacity, Says His Massachusetts Criminal Defense Lawyer" »

Today, the Boston Criminal Lawyer Blog sets its sight a bit further south. We look to Georgia and the case of Tonya Craft, the former kindergarten teacher who was charged with 22 counts of child molestation, aggravated sexual battery and aggravated child molestation. Her daughter along with the other three young accusers testified for the prosecution.

On Tuesday, the jury came back with the verdict of “Not Guilty”.

Hey, great, right? Justice was done and so it is big victory for Ms. Craft, yes?

Well, not so much. You see, win or lose, one's life is forever altered when such allegations come..

Craft describes that there are no winners in this type of situation. Her career is finished and she remains separated from her children who were taken away because of the allegations. There is also the matter of legal bills, stress on her family and supporters, not to mention stress on herself.

Not bad for a system that presumes innocence in a case where the person, at the end of the trial, remained so, huh?

Continue reading "The Boston Criminal Law Blog Questions Investigations and Prosecutions As Former Teacher Is Found Not Guilty Of Various Sexual Assaults" »

A jury has convicted 40-year-old David Flavell of assault with intent to rape a Massachusetts General Hospital employee. The 40-year-old former Salem resident, who before this latest incident was already registered as a Level 3 sex offender, was accused of attacking the woman inside the Boston hospital’s lobby bathroom last October. The jury also convicted Flavell of Massachusetts assault and battery and two counts of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon.

Prosecutors said that Flavell, who was waiting outside the woman’s restroom, followed the victim inside and placed an “out of order” sign on the door. They say that he pushed the victim’s head against the floor, tore her pants, hit her on the face, and tried to rape her before she got away. The Suffolk County District attorney’s office said that the “dangerous weapon” reference refers to the floor and the wall.

Because this is not Flavell’s first criminal offense, he could be sentenced to life in prison rather than the 20-years prison sentence that comes with a first conviction of assault with intent to rape. During the mid-1990’s, he was arrested in Salem for lewd sexual acts. He was convicted in Essex County in 1998 of assault with intent to rape. He was also arrested in Salem and Methuen six times for allegedly sexually pleasuring himself on clothes that were hanging in local stores. He was arrested in Salem in 2003 after he called a help line and said he was worried about what he might do. He was charged with making a false report. During a 2006 criminal trial, a Massachusetts Superior Court Judge determined that Flavell wasn’t a sexually dangerous person. Flavell was arrested in 2008 for peeping into a women’s stall at a Braintree bookstore.

Former Salem man convicted in sex assault case, Eagletribune.com, April 30, 2010

Sex offender convicted in MGH attack, Boston Herald, April 29, 2010

Related Web Resource:
Chapter 265: Section 24. Assault with intent to commit rape; weapons; punishment; eligibility for furloughs, education, training or employment programs, The General Laws of Massachusetts

Continue reading "Ex-Salem Resident Convicted of Attempted Boston Rape of Woman in Massachusetts General Hospital Bathroom " »

Two adults and three underage teen boys have been charged in connection with the gang-rape of a 7-year-old girl. The alleged victim’s 15-year-old stepsister has been charged with aggravated assault, promoting prostitution, and other crimes related to the case.

According to police, the 7-year-old was worried about her stepsister’s safety and went with her to a party. The teen had sex with a number of men in exchange for payment and also charged them to touch the 7-year-old. Police say that the touching became forcible sex and that seven men ended up raping the young girl. The men are accused of threatening to kill the 7-year-old if she screamed or reported the incident.

Among those arrested are 20-year-old Gregory Joseph Leary and 19-year-old Timear Lewis. The others that were apprehended are ages 17, 14, and 13. All five of them were charged with child endangerment and aggravated sexual assault. Leary has also been charged with having sex with a juvenile (the 15-year-old) too young to consent. The assault allegedly took place on March 28.

Even though nearly everyone arrested are juveniles, prosecutors may attempt to try everyone as adults.

Massachusetts Sex Crimes
You could find yourself in big legal trouble if charged with a Boston sexual assault crime. A conviction can lead to years in prison and a lifetime on the Massachusetts Sex Offender Registry Board, which will brand you as a convicted sex offender. It can be difficult to move on even after you have already completed your sentence and other penalties.

Outrage Follows Arrests in Rape of 7-Year-Old New Jersey Girl, ABC News, April 4, 2010

Five Charged in N.J. Child Rape Case; Girl, 7, Allegedly Pimped by Teen Sister, CBS News, April 5, 2010

Six Arrested After Girl, 7, Is Gang-Raped in New Jersey, The New York Times, April 3, 2010

Related Web Resources:
Massachusetts Law about Sex

Study: Many sex offenders are kids themselves, USA Today, January 5, 2010

Continue reading "Three Boys and Two Men Charged in Gang-Rape of 7-Year-Old " »

In Massachusetts, nine teenagers have been charged in connection with the death of Phoebe Prince. The 15-year-old was found hanging in her bedroom last January.

The teenagers are accused of stalking, harassment, and bullying Prince at South Hadley High School and on Facebook. Among those charged:

• 17-year-old Sean Mulveyhill from South Hadley is charged with criminal harassment, statutory rape, violation of civil rights, and disturbance of a school assembly.

• 17-year-old South Hadley teen Kayla Narey is charged with criminal harassment, civil rights violations, and disturbance of a school assembly.

• 18-year-old Austin Renaud from Springfield is charged with statutory rape.

• 16-year-old South Hadley resident teen Flannery Mullins is charged with stalking as a youthful offender and civil rights violations as a youthful offender.

• 16-year-old Ashley Longe, of South Handley, is charged with violation of civil rights as a youthful offender.

• 16-year-old Sharon Chanon Velazquez, of South Hadley, is charged with stalking as a youthful offender and civil rights violations as a youthful offender.

Three female juveniles, all South Hadley residents, have been charged with juvenile crimes, which include criminal harassment, civil rights violations, disturbance of a school assembly, and assault by means of a dangerous weapon.

Prince had moved to South Hadley from Ireland. According to Northwestern District Attorney Elizabeth Scheibel, one of the alleged bullying incidents occurred in front of a school staffer and other students, but no one reported what happened.

Bullying as a Crime
Many teenagers and younger children don’t realize when they’ve crossed the line that turns “merely picking on another kid” into a Massachusetts crime.

If your son or daughter has been charged with committing any crime, you should contact a Boston criminal defense lawyer to discuss your case.

9 charged in death of South Hadley teen, who took life after bullying, Boston.com, March 29, 2010

Phoebe Prince, South Hadley High School's 'new girl,' driven to suicide by teenage cyber bullies, New York Daily News, March 29, 2010

Related Web Resources:
Massachusetts Law About Bullying and Cyberbullying, Massachusetts Trial Court Libraries

Juvenile Crime in Massachusetts, Mass.gov

Continue reading "Nine Teenagers Indicted in Connection with Massachusetts 15-Year-Old’s Bullying Suicide" »

A 41-year-old registered sex offender has been arrested on charges of Massachusetts indecent assault and battery on a mentally challenged person and rape. Peter J. Duart was jailed on Martha's Vineyard.

He is a Level 2 sex offender. This means that Duart has been convicted of a sex crime that makes authorities think that he is in the mid level danger range when it comes to possibly offending again.

Massachusetts Sex Crimes
If you are charged with allegedly committing a sex crime in Massachusetts, know that prosecutors will likely aggressively pursue your case. Even if you did not commit the crime, there is a good chance that your reputation may be ruined and your relationships and professional life could suffer. This is why you should speak with a Boston sexual crimes lawyer as soon as possible.

You must get good legal representation. If you are convicted of the sex crime, you could end up in prison, be ordered to pay stiff fines, have to undergo counseling, and/or serve probation. You also will be permanently listed as a sexual offender on Massachusetts’ state registry. Anyone who goes to the registry will be able to access your name. If you have a prior conviction on your record, the charges against you and the sentence you may be ordered to serve can be enhanced.

Sex crime convictions that require that a person register as a Massachusetts sex offender:

• Aggravated rape
• Indecent assault and battery on a child under 14
• Indecent assault and battery on a person age 14 or over
• Indecent assault and battery on a mentally retarded person
• Rape of a child under 6 with force
• Rape
• Rape and abuse of a child
• Assault of a child with intent to commit rape
• Assault with intent to commit rape
• Kidnapping of a child
• Drugging persons for sexual intercourse
• Enticing a child under the age of 16 for the purposes of committing a crime
• Living off or sharing earnings with a minor prostitute
• Inducing a minor into prostitution
• A second conviction for open and gross lewdness and lascivious behavior (excludes a single or first adjudication as a delinquent juvenile prior to 8/1/92)
• Disseminating to a minor matter harmful to a minor
• Incestuous marriage or intercourse
• Unnatural or lascivious acts with a child under 16
• Posing or exhibiting a child in a state of nudity
• Aggravated rape
• Possession of child pornography

Registered sex offender nabbed on rape charge, Cape Cod Times, March 20, 2010

Information for Sex Offenders, Mass.gov

Related Web Resource:
Commonwealth of Massachusetts Sex Offender Registry Board

Continue reading "Registered Sex Offender Arrested for Alleged Massachusetts Rape of Mentally Challenged Person" »

Here is another arena in the Boston area where the hysterical cry of the Lawenorder Bird calls, “Softoncrime! Softoncrime!” The bird, considered a symbol of justice to some is seen as a predatory bird by others. Criminal defense attorneys for example.

The arena is one in which only one-half of its nesting area is visible to the general population. The nesting area is known as “The Administration”. The arenas are educational institutions littered throughout the Commonwealth. Academic in nature, they often do not consider certain real-life considerations. This makes them especially susceptible to public opinion.

And public opinion is almost always in favor of an easy answer to crush the problem of crime.

“Ok. Now what on Earth is he writing about today?”, you ask. “Predatory birds? Nests susceptible to public opinion? Has Sam Goldberg finally lost his grip?”

Continue reading "Attorney Sam’s Take: Massachusetts Campus Crime Report Seems To Contend That Sexual Assault Is Now “Acceptable” In College" »

A Middlesex Superior Court Grand Jury indicted Roger Lau and Thomas Heinz, both 26, on child rape charges yesterday. They are accused of raping the same girl.

Prosecutors say that both men assaulted a girl from the under-14 Medford girls soccer league that they were coaching. The alleged Massachusetts sexual assault crimes began taking place in 2003 and the last incident is said to have occurred during the summer of 2004.

The alleged victim, who was then 13 to 14 years of age, told police that she and Lau were sexually involved with each other for over a year. She claims that Heinz sexually assaulted her twice.

Lau was indicted on four counts of child rape by force and Heinz was indicted on one count of child rape by force. Both men have pleaded not guilty to the charges.

The two men were arrested last December. They are on pre-trial release and have been ordered not to have contact with children under age 16 unless these interactions are supervised. They also cannot coach or officiate any activities involving kids younger than 16.

Massachusetts Rape Charges
Allegations of rape are very serious—especially if the alleged victim is younger than 16. The state of Massachusetts does not consider an adult having sex with someone younger than 16 to ever be a consensual act and criminal charges can be filed against the adult. Punishments may be even more serious when violence or abuse is involved.

You have the right to an experienced Boston sex crimes lawyer who can defend you against all charges and protect your rights. Even if you are not guilty of committing any crime, your life can be irrevocably altered when you are accuse of rape.

Former Medford soccer coaches indicted on rape charges, Boston.com, February 5, 2010

Roger Lau, Thomas Heinz Accused Of Teen Soccer Child Rape, Huffington Post, December 22, 2009

Related Web Resource:
Massachusetts Law About Sex

Continue reading "Middlesex Superior Court Grand Jury Indicts Two Former Medford Soccer Coaches on Child Rape Charges " »

The game of politics is afoot again in the Boston area! This means that, as the race for the late Senator Kennedy’s seat comes to the wire, it is time for whatever mud can be thrown upon one’s opponent . Often, the accusations involve the criminal justice system. That’s where I come in. Today we look at accusations involving a 2005 rape case and Attorney General Martha Coakley.

In October, 2005, 31 year-old Somerville Police Officer Keith W. (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) was said to have raped his 23-month-old niece with a hot object, most likely a curling iron. The case was presented to a Middlesex grand jury which was overseen by Coakley. That grand jury did not take action against the Defendant. Thereafter, the child’s mother filed applications for criminal complaints in the case and it was then that the grand jury indicted the Defendant.

When the Defendant was before the court, the prosecution recommended that the Defendant not be held on bail, but released on personal recognizance. He remained free until December 2007, when he was found guilty.

Now, political opponents, both old and new, are taking the pulpit to decry Coakley’s handling of the case and making the typical cry of “too soft on crime”.

Continue reading "Boston AG Is Accused Of Mishandling Grand Jury Investigation And Bail Issues In Rape Case" »

Okay, here is the unfortunate truth of the matter – safeguarding Constitutional rights does not always bring happy results. Sometimes the cost is tragic. Most of the professionals involved in the criminal justice understand that. Massachusetts Kingston Police Chief Joseph Rebello is not one of those professionals apparently. I am guessing he is not a big fan of criminal defense attorneys either.

Nor is he likely to enjoy today’s blog.

The man at the heart of the story is Joseph G., a 26 year-old construction worker, of Kingston (hereinafter, the “Defendant”). He was arraigned last week on charges that he sexually assaulted a girlfriend’s 3-year-old daughter in Kingston. It was his second such charge. In fact, he had been charged this summer with raping another child.

The most recent matter came into being while the Defendant was free on bail.

Continue reading "On Massachusetts Probation, Child Rape Suspect Is Arrested For Second Sexual Assault While Out On Bail" »

A jury has found Michael D. Holden, a former Greater New Bedford Regional Vocational-Technical High School teacher, not guilty of two counts of forcible rape of a child. The alleged victim, who is now 20-years-old, had accused Holden of driving her to a parking lot, and, while in his SUV, forcing her to have sex and perform oral sex on him in 2004.

In January 2005, the school fired Holden after 14 years of employment. He also coached the boys volleyball team.

Holden’s criminal defense lawyer had accused the alleged victim of making up the allegations because the former teacher failed her for school work, recommended that the school suspend her, and admonished her several times for not dressing appropriately and being disruptive during class.

Following the announcement of the jury verdict, Holden expressed relief that he was exonerated.

Forcible Rape of a Child
In Massachusetts, a conviction of forcible rape of a child can lead to a lifelong prison sentence. This is considered a serious sexual offense and a violent crime. If you are under investigation for this crime, it is important that you consult with a Boston criminal defense lawyer right away.

Even as a suspect in a Massachusetts rape case, your reputation, career, and personal life can be thrown into turmoil. It is important that you have a legal team that knows how to provide you with the best defense.

Former teacher not guilty in rape case, SouthCoastToday, December 15, 2009

Ex-Teacher Not Guilty Of Child Rape, The Boston Channel, December 15, 2009

Related Web Resource:
Massachusetts Law About Sex, Massachusetts Trial Court Law Libraries

Continue reading "Former New Bedford Teacher is Not Guilty of Child Rape, Says Massachusetts Jury" »

“Look, you seem like a good kid. Boston needs more people out there like you…productive citizens. I have no interest in jamming you up. Just tell me your side of things and I will talk to the District Attorney and see what we can work out.”

You would be surprised how comforting those words seem when coming from the police officer who has you in the little room at the local police station talking about that nasty-sounding murder that everyone is upset about. You may be even more surprised at how many people leap to those words as if from a burning building to tell their “side of things.”

The next time they see that “side”, it is often almost unrecognizable as it reflects from the pages of a police report. Yep, the prosecution went through anyway. Who knew?

As most daily readers of this blog know, there is no law that says you must talk to the police when they come to question you. Quite the contrary. You have a Constitutional right not to talk to them. You have a right to ask for an attorney to be present as well.

“Well, Sam, if I say I do not want to talk to them, or ask for an attorney, aren’t I basically confessing that I have something to hide?”

Continue reading "Attorney Sam’s Take: MA Rape, Robbery Or Assault Charges – When To Talk To Police" »

Chris W., a 22-year-old Hanson man (hereinafter referred to as the “Defendant”) spent some time in court this week and undoubtedly got to meet a nice new criminal defense attorney.

The visit was occasioned by some pretty serious felony charges.

You see, apparently the Defendant and a young lady (hereinafter, the “Complainant”) went to Boston Saturday night. They went back to Hanson later and that is where the trouble is said to have started.

Apparently, the Complainant and the Defendant had an argument in her Hanson home. The women told police that the Defendant then went into her basement bedroom and forced himself on her, putting his hand on her mouth to muffle any screams. He then grabbed a plastic bag and put it over her head and lifted her up. As she tried to flee, he then is said to have thrown her to the floor and, banging her head against a wall and dresser, said, "You're lucky to be alive, and I should kill you."

Continue reading "A Night Out In Boston Results In Charges Of Rape, Attempted Murder And The Need For A Lawyer" »

Six family members have been arrested in connection with a child sex abuse investigation involving at least six alleged victims. The men who were arrested are Mohler brothers Burrell Edward, 53, David, 52, Jared Leroy, 48, and Roland Neil, 47, their 77-year-old father Burrell Edward Mohler, Sr., and his 72-year-old brother Darrel. Criminal charges against them include deviate sexual assault, rape, and use of a child in sexual performance. More charges are expected.

The Mohlers are accused of sexually abusing six of their relatives when the alleged victims were minors. Now adults, the people who have come forward are accusing the men of rape, forced abortions, mock weddings, and sexual performances.

Darrel Mohler, who has been charged with two counts of rape of a child under 14, says he knew “what was going on in Missouri” and had not been there since the ‘80s. He is accused of raping two relatives, age 6 and 5, during a sleepover. According to prosecutors, after the alleged incident, Burrell Mohler Sr. told the crying girls to be careful that the waterbed didn’t burst and drown them.

Another man, Mark Young, says his son is also a sex abuse victim. Young’s ex-wife married Burrell Edward Mohler Jr. Young says his son was 7 at the time of the alleged child sex abuse.

The alleged assaults are said to have occurred between the mid ‘80’s and at least through the mid 90’s. Police are looking for at least one body.

Burrell Mohler Sr., Jared Mohler, and David Mohler are lay ministers with the Community of Christ Church, which has since suspended their priesthood licenses.

Another man, Mohler family associate Larry Kidd, was arrested but later released. At this time he has not been charged and is working with investigators.

Police arrest sixth member of family accused of child sex abuse, CNN, November 14, 2009

Sixth Man Charged in Mohler Child Sex Case, Fox4kc.com, November 13, 2009

Father, 4 sons in court on sex charges, UPI, November 12, 2009

Related Web Resources:
Massachusetts Laws About Sex

Sex Offenders, Mass.gov

Continue reading "Sixth Family Members Arrested for Child Sex Abuse" »

Citing a lack of evidence, the Suffolk District Attorney's office says it will not file Massachusetts rape charges against a male Boston police officer accused of sexually assaulting a fellow cop. The announcement comes after prosecutors and detectives conducted a probe into the allegations by the female officer, who says that the male cop sexually assaulted her numerous times in August and September.

Boston Police detectives examined phone records, text messages, hotel records, and other documents, as well as interviewed over two dozen people. The female officer’s husband says that he and his wife plan to keep pursuing the case. They say the sexual assaults took place in several jurisdictions, including Boston.

The female officer says that the male cop forced her to have sex on several occasions and she became pregnant. She says that she had sex with him when he demanded it because she was scared of him.

The male cop has always maintained his innocence.

Massachusetts Rape
Rape allegations are very serious accusations against someone and the punishment for committing this type of sexual assault can be very serious. Not everyone accused of rape is guilty of the crime it is important that a suspect obtain the best representation possible to ensure the best defense against these charges.

Prosecutors will not pursue rape case against Boston police officer, Boston.com, November 2, 2009

Boston Cop Denies Raping Fellow Officer, WBZ, October 5, 2009

Text Messages Raise Questions About Cop's Rape Claim, The Boston Channel, October 3, 2009

Related Web Resources:
Police Department: City of Boston

Suffolk District Attorney's Office

Continue reading "Suffolk District Attorney Says Not Enough Evidence to Pursue Massachusetts Rape Case Against Boston Cop Accused of Assaulting Female Police Officer" »

As I write this year’s Halloween Attorney Sam's Take, I know that goblins, vampires and politicians are roaming around outside circling the streets of Salem, Boston and environs. Of course, as I've noted several times, that is not terribly new; it has been going on since October 1st! I had thought of dressing up in costume tonight to scare people as well. Then, I realized that it would be redundant…I’m a lawyer. People already avoid us like the plague.

Last year, I wrote a Halloween blog about the question of witch hunts. We entertained the question of whether or not they were really a thing of the past. We came to the conclusion that they were not. Only the names and faces of the targets have changed.

I don't see any reason to believe that this has changed much over the year. I do think, however, that we have been provided with a good example of how today’s “witches” can finally redeem themselves.

As I was growing up, and then again later when I was in law school, the late Michael Jackson was a beloved superstar. His talents, whether with his brothers or without them, were many and his following was enormous. There have been many public figures in our history who caught our hearts, became beloved and then, finally, were reviled. Granted, Michael seemed to lead the charge in his own publicity downfall. But he did follow the same familiar path. After ensuring himself legendary status, releasing the albums Thriller and Bad, his behavior seemed to become more and more…unusual. As he continued to release masterpieces we heard tales of bidding on the remains of the Elephant Man, sleeping in an oxygen tank and bleaching his skin. Then there was Neverland, kids and sleep-overs. Soon enough, there were blackmail threats and, finally, the criminal prosecution for sex crimes against children. Those of us who were not convinced of his guilt had to admit that simply labeling Michael as “strange” was like calling Hell "tepid"

Continue reading "Attorney Sam’s Halloween Take: Tales Of Sex Crimes, Death And Salvation" »

Four teens were arraigned yesterday in connection with the alleged gang rape of a 15-year-old girl on her high school campus:

• Cody Ray Smith, 15, pleaded not guilty to rape by force and rape with a foreign object.

• Ari Abdallah Morales, 16, did not enter a plea.

• Marcelles James Peter, 17, did not enter a plea.

• Manuel Ortega, 19, did not enter a plea.

The four teenagers are charged as adults. Another person, an adult, has also been arrested. His arraignment will take place on another day.

Smith, Peter, and Morales wore bulletproof vests at the hearing. The four teenagers are accused of participating in a 2 ½ hour gang rape of the victim on Saturday outside a Richmond, California high school.

Police claim that up to 10 people sexually assaulted the young girl, while 10 other people watched. None of them contacted 911. According to a 1999 state law, not reporting a crime that one has witnessed is only illegal if the victim is younger than 15. This means that police do not have the authority to arrest the people who were watching the assailants who raped the girl.

The victim, who was in critical condition following the assault, was released from the hospital yesterday. Police found her under a bench and unconscious after they responded to a 911 call from someone who heard people who were allegedly at the rape scene talking about what they’d witnessed.

Massachusetts Rape Crimes
Allegations of rape are very serious—especially when there are multiple parties involved. It is important that you retain the services of an experienced Boston criminal defense lawyer who can look through all the evidence and provide you with the best defense possible.

Police have been known to arrest the wrong person or get their facts wrong. Evidence may have been tampered with or a suspect’s rights may have been violated during the arrest.

4 arraigned in California gang rape case, CNN, October 29, 2009

No one called cops during gang rape, but some took pictures, ABC, October 27, 2009

Related Web Resources:
Massachusetts Law About Rape and Sexual Assault, Massachusetts Trial Court Law Libraries

Juvenile Crimes in Massachusetts (PDF)

Continue reading "Four Teenagers Arraigned in Alleged Gang Rape of 15-Year-Old Girl" »

At his arraignment last week in Falmouth District Court, Bourne Deputy Fire Chief Paul Weeks pleaded not guilty to one charge of oral rape and two charges of rape. Court documents indicate that the alleged rape occurred on October 20 and that Weeks was under the influence of alcohol at the time.

The Bourne deputy fire chief was released on his own recognizance after the hearing. Weeks’s criminal defense lawyer told the Cape Cod Times that his client is innocent.

In another Bourne rape case, Plymouth resident Stephen Clifford pleaded guilty to raping a North Sagamore woman last year. The woman was sexually assaulted and bound with duck tape. Clifford is sentenced to 9 – 12 years in prison.

Massachusetts rape charges can be hard to beat without the help of an experienced Boston criminal defense lawyer representing you. There may be evidence in your favor that hasn’t been looked at or the suspect’s side of the story may have gotten lost in the shuffle during the police investigation. Police may even have arrested the wrong person. A good Massachusetts criminal defense law firm can make sure that you get the best defense possible so that you obtain the best outcome for your case.

On Friday, David Flavell, a registered Level 3 sex offender, was charged with sexual assault. The victim is a 27-year-old hospital worker. Flavell allegedly assaulted her in the bathroom located in Massachusetts General Hospital’s lobby.

Flavell, however, says he had been drinking at the time and does not remember the crime happening. He was arraigned in Boston on charges of Massachusetts assault and battery by means of a dangerous weapon and assault with intent to rape.

Plymouth man admits to Bourne rape, Cape Cod Times, October 26, 2009

Bourne deputy fire chief in charged with rape, Boston Herald, October 22, 2009

Related Web Resources:
Massachusetts Law about Rape and Sexual Assault

Sex Offender Registry Board, Commonwealth of Massachusetts