Boston Criminal Lawyer Blog

…And so students and their families alike are awakening to the passing of the season. Summer is exiting Massachusetts, and school is beginning. This time, though, things are a bit more serious. First of all, as discussed yesterday, the Boston area seems to be in the middle of a dramatic increase in murder cases. Violent alleged criminals aside, however, what once was not unusual juvenile school behavior will now be viewed under the type of criminal justice microscope that inevitably brings new arrests.

As you will recall, the Massachusetts legislature brought into being a new anti-bullying statute last year. It is now in effect and, because of its vagueness, has school districts scrambling to figure out how to adhere to it.

At the same time, there are attorneys who have adjusted their practices so that they may open the new specialty to capitalize on the new statute and attention on bullying behavior.

Meanwhile, I am a criminal defense attorney with many years of experience. I also am focusing on the new statute and the mess it is about to bring the system. Said mess began when a bunch of kids were indicted last year for bullying activities on which another student’s suicide was originally blamed.

The truth is that, for the most part, what was illegal to do remains illegal to do.

Let’s take some examples:

Continue reading "Attorney Sam’s Take: The MA Landscape Of Bullying, Assault and Harassment For Students And Parents" »

September is a-coming. It would appear that it will soon be time, once again in Massachusetts, for those school-time hijinks like bullying, assault and vandalism.

And police investigations.

Well, it looks like some people just can’t wait. No, not a high school or college campus crime this time. The event took place at Julia F. Callahan Elementary School in Lynn this past weekend. Vandals trashed the school, dumping paint, spraying fire extinguishers, shattering glass, overturning desks and copiers, and spewing classroom materials throughout the building, according to Deputy Superintendent Jaye Warry and Lieutenant William Sharp of the Lynn Police Department.

The police describe that the “school was entered and extensively vandalized,’’ Superintendent Warry, who has worked in the Lynn school system for 25 years, said this break in was “up there on the extent of damage.’’ She went on to say that the vandalism affected most of the two-story building and that the principal’s office was destroyed.

Continue reading "Attorney Sam Warns Students About Criminal Investigations After Lynn MA School Is Vandalized" »

Here is another one in a series of people being prosecuted for having parties wherein juveniles are allegedly given alcohol. As mentioned last week, ‘tis the season apparently.

Specifically, Elizabeth M., 50, and her son Taylor, 18, of Cohasset ( hereinafter, collectively, the “Defendants”) now face charges in Quincy District Court. They have pleaded not guilty yesterday to charges that they hosted an underage drinking party that drew dozens of teenagers to their home on Saturday night. Her charges include furnishing alcohol to minors under the ‘‘social host law,’’ keeping a disorderly house, and disturbing the peace. He faces charges of furnishing alcohol to minors and being a minor in possession of alcohol.

Both were ordered to abstain from drugs and alcohol and undergo in-home sobriety testing, while they wait for trial.

Continue reading "Cohasset MA Mother And Son Charged Giving Alcohol To Juveniles – A Boston Criminal Attorney’s View" »

Here is something a Boston Criminal Lawyer does not see every day. The father of a tragically deceased daughter, who’s death the Commonwealth is looking use as a tool of political expediency, is showing the compassion.

You remember the word “compassion”, don’t you? It is the word I used when discussing the tragedy and the problem of bullying in the first place.

Yes, I am referring to the father of the late Phoebe Prince, who committed suicide earlier this year. The local prosecutor decided to blame the death on local bullies and take the extra step of indicting the kids. Now, with Ms. Prince dead, other potential reasons for the suicide coming to light, her father, unlike the “cool heads” of law enforcement, is said to be seeking “justice, not vengeance”.

Jeremy Prince, the father, in an interview with the online publication slate.com, said he would be willing to ask a judge for leniency if his daughter's alleged tormentors expressed their remorse in open court.

Continue reading "MA Bullying Victim’s Dad Suggests Leniency In Sentencing Of Students" »

Well, we began this week on the Boston Criminal Lawyer Blog discussing crimes that occur in the summer. Yesterday, I was reminded of a companion crime to drunk driving and too much partying.

Two Palmer residents now face criminal charges that they supplied alcohol to a 17-year-old boy who later died in a dirt bike accident.

For those of you who are not sure, the drinking age is currently 21.

Police say 45-year-old Robin K. and 28-year-old Kenneth D. (hereinafter collectively, the “Defendants”) will be summoned to appear in court on charges of procuring alcohol for a minor.

Detective Sgt. Scott Haley told the Republican newspaper of Springfield that
the teenager, Erik N. (hereinafter, the “Deceased”), drank alcohol during a bonfire in April at the apartment complex where the Defendants live.

Continue reading "MA Couple Are Charged With Giving Alcohol To Juvenile After Deadly Traffic Accident" »

Gee, it seems like only yesterday that this Boston criminal defense attorney was going against the grain and calling the indictment of six kids from South Hadley a senseless exercise of political grandstanding…or words to that effect. Don’t believe that I saw what everybody else was heralding as “heroic” as folly? Check out my postings since January as well as my comments on the equally “heroic” legislation on both the blog and Fox25!

Now, a couple of developments have some people reconsidering the events.

When 15-year-old Phoebe Prince committed suicide in January, six fellow South Hadley students were blamed for relentlessly bullying her. It was an easy fix for SuperDA Elizabeth Scheibel – indict them all and ruin their lives.

Whoops!

A new report shows there may have been factors other than bullying that led to the death of the South Hadley student.

Court documents, recently obtained by Emily Bazelon of the online magazine Slate, contain police interviews with Phoebe's mother, classmates, teachers and administrators that tell a different story; one that suggests the teen's troubles extended beyond the halls of South Hadley High.

Continue reading "Massachusetts Bullying Indictments And Legislation Controversy Are Revisited In New Reports" »

Yesterday, the Boston Globe’s front page reflected the start of a new series of articles on students, families and schools. It described the plight of Lexi, a 14-year-old girl who began classes at a new school in an “affluent suburb” west of Boston.

According to the story, Lexi’s torment began within the first few days, when a “friend” texted her the message, “Go online.’’

“Online” being shorthand for “facebook”, Lexi went to the page to find pictures a girlfriend had taken a few months before of Lexi making faces at the camera. After the posting were a string of brilliant comments like, “You look like a rat that has been put on crack . . . in other words ugly as balls,’’ and “ hahaha”.

This was a terrific blow. After all, Lexi had realized that how she looked mattered a great deal in how she was or was not accepted. Now, there was a picture of her looking like a kid, neither polished nor particularly attractive..

“I knew from the beginning,’’ Lexi says now. “I knew it was basically everyone against me.’’

Sure enough, in the months that followed, she was taunted at school. Boys called her foul names and girls snickered. Finally, the problem worsened as groups of students picked on her, surrounding her on the stairs or pushing her in the cafeteria. She even received threatening calls on her cell phone.

Continue reading "Assaults, Threats And Bullying In Boston Schools – Will The Law Help? (Part One)" »

As a Boston criminal defense attorney, there is an oft-said and ill-fated sentence claimed by clients. It reads, “…but I didn’t know that was illegal!”

Unfortunately, such lack of knowledge does not usually matter. They really mean it when they say “ignorance of the law is no excuse”. Further, there are times when ignorance of the facts is basically irrelevent.

A prime example of the latter is the case of statutory rape. “But I didn’t know she was just shy of her thirteenth birthday…she told me she was twenty-five” is not going to be a viable defense.

Another example is something that a psychiatrist who teaches at Harvard Medical School (clearly not an ignorant man by any estimation, yet, hereinafter, the “Defendant”) said this week about the trouble in which he has now found himself.

He had been hosting a graduation party in New Hampshire. He has released a statement that he didn't know that there were students drinking at the high school graduation party .

Apparently, however, there were.

Continue reading "A Boston Criminal Defense Attorney’s View Of Knowledge And Guilt In The Criminal Justice System" »

The Boston Globe posted a “snapshot” on May 13th reviewing how busy the various Massachusetts are in terms of criminal cases. You can view it here.

As one can see, the number of criminal defendants handled by the different district courts varies widely. Springfield and Worcester, for example, saw more than 11,000 defendants each in 2009. Six courts saw fewer than 1,000. These were Gloucester, Winchendon, Newton, Brookline, Ipswich and Nantucket.

Generally, the busiest courts are the ones nearest metropolitan areas. Thus, Dorchester and Roxbury are liable to be busier than Newburyport or Sandwich.

Depending on the areas, some criminal cases are more prevalent than others. For example, you can expect more homicide cases to be passing through on their way to indictment in the busier courtrooms than someplace like Ipswich.

Another variable that can effect how busy is a certain court is the presence of schools, particularly high school and college. As we have discussed, this is likely to grow given the new bullying law.

Continue reading "A BOSTON CRIMINAL LAW ATTORNEY REVIEWS CRIMES AND CRIMINAL DEFENDANTS IN DISTRICT COURTS IN 2009" »

The Boston Criminal Lawyer Blog has been discussing school campus related crimes of late. Most of these have had to do with the subject of bullying, a topic I just know we will be returning to. Yesterday, we briefly discussed a different kind of criminal behavior by a student. This one is a bit less sympathetic.

The story hails from the home of Altman & Altman LLP’s main office...Cambridge. It involves the legendary Harvard University and an ex-student who allegedly took the subjects of creative writing and social science and twisted them into a pretzel of deceit and larceny. It features the allegations against the former student with contradictory credentials, Adam B. Wheeler...perhaps a young Bernard Madoff in the making.

As you probably have heard, young Mr. Wheeler is facing a plethora of criminal charges and there may be more to come. The 20 indictments against him reflect a successful scheme to bilk Harvard University out of approximately $45,000 through a series of white collar crimes. He is alleged to have falsified documents, plagiarized and lied in order to gain acceptance into Harvard, gain scholarships, win prizes and get a grant.

In fact, should the allegations contain a cyber-fraud element crossing state boundries, which is likely, Young Wheeler could be looking at federal charges as well as those he faces by the Commonwealth.

Of course, now that the news has broken and he has pleaded “Not Guilty”, the ignited debate rages on. Everyone is trying to explain who the young gentleman is and how he did what he (allegedly) did.

For example, a former high school classmate claims that the lad was a class clown who delighted in pranks such as tossing ketchup packets around the halls like little red landmines. Further, she doubts anyone expected him capable of the complex scam that prosecutors say he pulled on some of America’s best brains in Harvard University’s hallowed halls.

Continue reading "Academic Voices From Ex-Harvard Student's Past Display Surprise At The Fraud and Theft Charges Against Him" »

Adam B. Wheeler, a former Harvard student who has been indicted for falsifying information that allowed him to get into the university and receive thousands of dollars in financial aid and grants, has pleaded not guilty to 20 criminal counts of identify fraud, larceny, pretending to hold a degree, and falsifying an endorsement or approval. At the 23-year-old’s arraignment today, his cash bail was set at $5,000. If convicted, Wheeler could be sentenced to a maximum of five years in prison for each felony count and a year for each misdemeanor.

Wheeler is accused of submitting bogus transcripts that showed him attending Phillips Academy and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. He also allegedly falsified his perfect SAT test score of 1600 and included fake letters of recommendation with his college application.

Assistant Middlesex District Attorney John Verner says that in fact, Wheeler had actually attended a Delaware high school, earned 1100 on his SAT, and was studying a Bowdoin College before he was suspended for plagiarizing an essay. He then applied to transfer to Harvard after the Spring 2007 semester.

Prosecutors claim that Wheeler plagiarized letters of recommendation and essays and made other allegedly “untruthful” statements when applying for Fulbright and Rhodes Scholarships. They claim that he defrauded Harvard of more than $45,000, including $31,806 in financial aid, $6,000 in English prizes, and $8,000 for a research grant.

It was when he applied for the Rhodes and Fulbright Scholarships in September 2009 that a Harvard professor began to suspect that Wheeler had committed plagiarism. Wheeler then decided to leave Harvard. He is also accused of submitting fraudulent documents, including fake letters of recommendation, to Brown and Yale when he submitted transfer applications to both schools.

Wheeler's Cambridge criminal defense lawyer says that it is important to remember that the charges against his client are “just allegations” and that Wheeler should be “presumed innocent” until proven guilty. This is the 23-year-old’s first brush with the law.

Parents stepped in after alleged Harvard scammer applied to Yale, Boston.com, May 18, 2010

Ex-Harvard Student, Adam Wheeler, Pleads Not Guilty to Charges of Fabricating Academic History, The Harvard Crmson, May 18, 2010

Related Web Resource:
Harvard University

Continue reading "Ex-Harvard Student Pleads Not Guilty to Identity Fraud, Larceny, and Other Massachusetts Criminal Charges in Alleged Fraud that Earned Him Admission, Grants, and Financial Aid " »

In the Boston area, nine young men, ages ranging from 15 to 21 are now in need of criminal defense attorneys. They are accused of horribly assaulting a 19 year old developmentally disabled teenager in Dorchester.

They left him bloodied and screaming for help, the prosecutor said.

Suffolk County District Attorney Daniel F. Conley issued the statement that ''A crime like this just shocks the conscience...It’s obscene."

The scene of yesterday’s arraignments was a familiar one. The court read the charges, the prosecutor filled in the blanks, adding the detail and commentary about the allegations and the defense attorneys denied all guilt for their clients who were basically “good kids”.

As is often the case in such matters, there are differing views of what happened. While the defendant is not required to give his this early, or, actually, at all, there are claims that some of the nine defendants were actually trying to help the victim, not attack him.

The attack came to the attention of law enforcement when police were called by a man who apparently witnessed it shortly before 5:00 PM on Monday. His attention was drawn to it when he was working in his back yard and heard a "God-awful scream”.

Continue reading "Nine Boston Youths Are Charged With Assault And Battery In Bullying Attack Of Disabled Teen" »

22-year-old George Huguely, a member of the University of Virginia’s lacrosse team, has been arrested and charged with the first-degree murder of Yeardley Love, also age 22 and a member of the school’s women’s lacrosse team. According to police, Huguely and Love were romantically involved with each other and had just broken up.

On Monday at around 2:15 am, police were called to Love’s apartment over a possible alcohol overdose. However, Charlottesville Police Chief Tim Longo says that it became obvious that Love, who was found in a pool of blood in her bedroom, had experienced “obvious physical trauma.”

Police say that they found Huguely at his apartment and questioned him. He was arrested later that morning. Huguely has admitted that he and Love were having a disagreement when he shook her. He says that her head struck the wall more than once. The 22-year-old college athlete also admitted to kicking open Love’s bedroom door and taking her computer.

Huguely’s criminal defense lawyer is calling Love's death a “tragic accident.” Prior to enrolling at the University of Virginia, the 22-year-old was a high school All-American. The university lacrosse team that he belongs to is nationally ranked No. 1 in the U.S. Intercollegiate Lacrosse Association coaches' poll.

Massachusetts College Campus Crimes
If you are a college student who was arrested and charged with committing a crime on or off a Massachusetts college campus, it is important that you obtain legal representation as soon as possible. The outcome of your Boston college campus criminal case could determine whether or not you receive federal funding to cover your education, get into the graduate school of your choice, get a good job after college, or end up with a criminal record for life.

It can be scary to know that the future you’ve been working so hard for may be in jeopardy because you are under investigation or charged with a drug crime, drunk driving, underage drinking, sexual assault, rape, murder, stalking, cyber crime, larceny, assault and battery, larceny, shoplifting, vandalism, or any other criminal activity.

UVA lacrosse player George Huguely admits fight, hiding Yeardley Love's computer after death: docs, NY Daily News, May 4, 2010

Lacrosse player George Huguely charged in fellow U

Affidavit: Lacrosse Player Killed In Fight fter Breakup, WIBW.com

Related Web Resources:
University of Virginia

University of Virginia Men's Lacrosse

Virginia Cavaliers

Continue reading "Campus Crime: University of Virginia Male Lacrosse Player Charged with First-Degree Murder in Death of Female Lacrosse Player" »